What's the worst judges' decision of the year?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Sir_Jose
    El Guapo
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Dec 2003
    • 4935
    • 424
    • 383
    • 13,646

    #31
    what people dont seem to get is that there is a difference between a close fight and a robbery

    Burton/Augustus was BY FAR the worst of the year

    Comment

    • Pound4Pound1986
      Bernard Hopkins
      Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
      • Oct 2004
      • 540
      • 44
      • 35
      • 7,051

      #32
      Originally posted by jose
      what people dont seem to get is that there is a difference between a close fight and a robbery

      Burton/Augustus was BY FAR the worst of the year
      yea i have to agree with you and they didnt even know how to call fights

      Comment

      • Hurlex
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Aug 2004
        • 1625
        • 72
        • 0
        • 7,834

        #33
        augustus hands down

        right behind him is the santos/margarito robbery in Puerto rico

        also sturm got robbed bad...sturm had almost 100 punches connected more then dlh

        Comment

        • chito
          Banned
          Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
          • Apr 2004
          • 900
          • 531
          • 270
          • 14,864

          #34
          to me, it was felix sturm-oscar dela hoya fight! just because dela hoya-hopkins fight is waiting there at the side, they would let this happen and award the fight to dela hoya? if we watch the tape again, sturm was the clear winner there so i am voting for this fight! no controversy for pac-man and marquez, it was a close call but the judge who admitted he made a mistake judging for a 10-7 count should be banned! i don't get it why he admitted it although the fight was over and the decision has already been given to the fight. he should have sticked to his previous judgement which is 10-7!

          Comment

          • psychopath
            Banned
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Aug 2004
            • 5085
            • 196
            • 266
            • 5,396

            #35
            Originally posted by chito
            to me, it was felix sturm-oscar dela hoya fight! just because dela hoya-hopkins fight is waiting there at the side, they would let this happen and award the fight to dela hoya? if we watch the tape again, sturm was the clear winner there so i am voting for this fight! no controversy for pac-man and marquez, it was a close call but the judge who admitted he made a mistake judging for a 10-7 count should be banned! i don't get it why he admitted it although the fight was over and the decision has already been given to the fight. he should have sticked to his previous judgement which is 10-7!

            Why the judge admitted it? Well because sooner or later that mistake gonna be discovered and brought out in the open. If he didn't admit it as early as he did, that judge is going to be accused of altering the result of the fight intentionally. He wanted to clear his name and put that incident as a case of plain and simple error.

            Controversy on that Pacquiao/Marquez fight? Well I will go back to my original contention, it is still unbelievable and unacceptable for me to accept that the REF and a JUDGE would screw up big time at the same time in a fight of such magnitude and stature. It's hard to prove anything so that will stay as is . . . and who's the promoter for that DLH/Sturm fight? . . .suprised? I just hope and pray that Arum suffers a heart attack that would paralize half of his body . . . . no I don't want him dead yet . . . I want him to suffer as payback for the injustices he had commited against the fighters and the sport.

            Comment

            • ELPacman
              LEGENDARY
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Apr 2004
              • 10792
              • 1,957
              • 151
              • 34,372

              #36
              Yeah Pac-Marquez has to take my vote of course though without a doubt I'll never forget Juarez-Raheem. Jaurez got saved by the ref without a doubt. I'm sure that ref will be banned. It was disgusting watching it. Maybe the ref wanted to get popular or something because he was the main focus once he got into the habit of yelling at Raheem every 10 seconds.

              As for the Pac-Marquez scoring. Ya know it was a close fight though in the end where it matters, if you score everything properly, Pac should have gotten the win. Making these Oops, I didn't know I was suppose to do that or, people usually don't give 10-6s, that's just bad for the sport. Boxing is a hard sport as is with all the corruption. With a judge admitting his wrong scoring AFTER the fight just takes that to the next level. I'll tell you this though, Arum is very good at protecting his fighters...

              Comment

              • dempseyfire
                Interim Champion
                Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                • Dec 2003
                • 872
                • 25
                • 3
                • 7,042

                #37
                Come One!!!!!

                A REAL robbery is the Burton fight. COme on, Marquez-Pacman and Byrd-Golota were close fights and were not clear robberies at all. Just b/c your favorite fighter is in a close fight doesn't mean he won . . .

                Comment

                • Sir_Jose
                  El Guapo
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Dec 2003
                  • 4935
                  • 424
                  • 383
                  • 13,646

                  #38
                  Originally posted by dempseyfire
                  A REAL robbery is the Burton fight. COme on, Marquez-Pacman and Byrd-Golota were close fights and were not clear robberies at all. Just b/c your favorite fighter is in a close fight doesn't mean he won . . .

                  exactly

                  people who dont know boxing dont understand the difference between a close fight and a robbery

                  Comment

                  • phallus
                    the lizard of ahs
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Sep 2004
                    • 12066
                    • 4,352
                    • 3,349
                    • 50,135

                    #39
                    he wuz robbed!!!

                    No question, Augustus vs. Burton was the worst case of home
                    cooking i've seen in years. I saw that fight, several rounds went by without Burton landing a single punch and they had him winning. BULL****!!! ...Also Byrd - Oquendo, Byrd lost that fight and the judges gave him an early Xmas present

                    Comment

                    • Swifty
                      Contender
                      • Oct 2004
                      • 107
                      • 9
                      • 0
                      • 6,379

                      #40
                      Sturm vs DLH. That was a straight ***ing robbery

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP