What's the worst judges' decision of the year?

[Dark Destroyer]

I'll say the Oscar-Mosley 2 fight purely because most people thought Oscar had won that fight. Shane looked so pissed off at the end waitng for that result, he looked like a beaten man. I remember watching that fight with my friends and most of them aren't bothered about boxing and even they thought Oscar had won. He wasn't given a fair decision there. You can always count on the judges to mess things up, luckily Oscar had a big enough reputation to be able to bounce back from that loss and land a good fight.
I have to mention the Marquez-Pcaman fight too, i thought Marquez had just taken that fight. I was so shocked to see how he turned that fight around from that dreadful first round. It's fighters like Marquez that make the term "Heart" just.

[urdaddyinAZ]

For my money I'll take Juarez/Raheem......combination of the horrendous referee and the fact that Raheem still won in my mind despite having all the points taken. That Griffin fight the other night was disgusting too.

[dberce1]

definitely sturm/delahoya

[urdaddyinAZ]

I just don't see how people can have Sturm-DLH as their number one. The fight was super close, but I just don't see it as a travesty. I have watched over and over again and I still have DLH winning by the narrowest of margins. Even if I had it the other way, I wouldn't find it appauling. Same with JMM-Pacman....I had PAC winning but a draw wasn't so off base that I was pissed off. Watch the Burton.....Griffin...and Raheem fights and you'll some serious BS. These other two fights just are stuck in people's mind cause they involved big names.

[mic573]

The Delahoya/Sturm fight was close as was the Pacquiao/Marquez fight. I had Sturm winning the fight by either 116-112 or 115-113. It always flip flops between those to scores. I have Marquez beating Pac everytime I scored that fight though it was close. There were times I came up with a draw 113-113. All the scores with the 10-6 first round. The Raheem fight I feel was closer than what people say. I thought Raheem won but with the deductions I had Juarez winning.

[m00ks]

For the Pac-JMM, I had Pac winning 114-111 everytime I scored. Once I went as close as 113-112 but still for Pac. It was the 3 point first round that really hurt JMM.

As for the judge who scored that round 10-7. I just don't get it. Give a boxer his due. Had he knocked down JMM twice, the score would have still been 10-7. So why did he close his eyes for the third knockdown and denied Pac of that point that was well earned. Don't make sense to me.

Also why I think JMM-Pac had the worst scoring is because of the discrepancy in both cards. I mean one had it 115-110 for Pac and the other 115-110 JMM. That means they saw the fight completely different. 10 point difference between both cards!! As fans I would understand. But as judges? Come on...

[teakay]

The Augustus fight was the worse. It was like the Roy Jones loss in the Olympics, pure BS.

The Pac-Marquez fight was a bad decison. 115-110 Marquez??? Why where Pac's people pissed, and Marquez's people okay with the decision?

A knockdown = minus 1 point, that's part of the rules. Not taking the point is just like scoring a touchdown and not getting points for it.

[psychopath]

I know it, a judge should be perminity banned for not understanding how to score a fight-- that's what he there to do.

Everybody has their eyes on that SENILE JUDGE . . . what about ****** Cortez . . . he should be under an inquiry rightnow for failing to deduct a point after so many low blow warnings . . . the rule is very very clear on this one . . . a violation of the same after two warnings should results in a point deduction.

Knowing boxing for so long . . .In a fight of such big stature . . . It's unbelievable that a Ref and a JUDGE would **** UP BIGTIME at the same time.

[m00ks]

Everybody has their eyes on that SENILE JUDGE . . . what about ****** Cortez . . . he should be under an inquiry rightnow for failing to deduct a point after so many low blow warnings . . . the rule is very very clear on this one . . . a violation of the same after two warnings should results in a point deduction.

Knowing boxing for so long . . .In a fight of such big stature . . . It's unbelievable that a Ref and a JUDGE would **** UP BIGTIME at the same time.

There was also the question of to what language teh ref should count on. Cortez counted slow to me. In spanish also, more syllables.

[THRILLAinmanila]

The Professor

PAQUIAO-Marquez

The nod should have been to the PacMan.