Who has fought the best competition, 2005-8?

[Tuggers1986]

Taylor! easily

[MELLY-MEL...]

Jermain Taylor

Pacquiao should be on that list, but I would still slightly favor Taylor...

[Left2body]

I voted for Taylor but I believe honorable mention should be given to Mayorga.

Mayorga had: Forrest, Forrest, Spinks, Judah, Tito, DLH.

However I think this goes back to 04 IIRC but either way thats a tough sled to pull.

[kayjay]

I forgot Pac and didn't think of Mayorga.

Also counting 2008 Hopkins has: Taylor, Taylor, Tarver, Wright, Calzaghe

[xfiles]

Hopkins easy, Taylor twice, Tarver, Wright, Calzaghe..... No easy fights in between.

Why isn't Joke Calzaghe on this list? Look at his stellar line up of fights since 2005:

Mario Veit
Evans Ashira
Jeff Lacy
Sakio Bika
Peter Manfredo
Mikkel Kessler

That's a who's who of boxing right there, folks...

[slicksouthpaw16]

Hopkins (Twice)
Wright
Ouma
Spinks
Pavlik (Twice)

From the list, i would say Taylor.

[Ray*]

Why isn't Joke Calzaghe on this list? Look at his stellar line up of fights since 2005:

Mario Veit
Evans Ashira
Jeff Lacy
Sakio Bika
Peter Manfredo
Mikkel Kessler

That's a who's who of boxing right there, folks...

LOL you're a joker mate.

[Motofan]

Taylor by a mile. He really never fights an easy fight.