(Prime) Roy Jones Jr vs Joe Calzaghe

[nvme]

Thats your opinion. I have mine. Lets leave it at that.

aight. i just want you to know that i respect ur opinion because you didnt actually say joe will win. you said he would give jones a good fight. respect. ur entitled to ur opinion. n im entitled to mine.

[shadowboxa]

Its tough but I reckon Calzaghe on points!

[RichCCFC]

I think Joe would win but I can see arguements from both sides.

[IMDAZED]

You guys must be on drugs.

Joe Calzaghe has NEVER beaten the kind of fighters Jones whupped in his prime, never shown the amount of skill Jones showed in his prime...and you're seriously asking this question.

Show of hands, how many of y'all started watching boxing in earnest in the 21st century? I mean, you base this on Calzaghe's wins over Lacy and Kessler?

Just wow...

[Left2body]

I would LOVE to hear Scully's thoughts and oppinion on this fantasy matchup.

I'm personally going with RJJ with an easy Win. Yeah I said easy because he fought 2 HOF's when they were in or around there prime and he beat them easily and made them look pedestrian.

RJJ has been fighting at LW and above for so long people forget how much power he had at SMW.

[Knicksman20]

Cal is a good fighter; Roy was a great fighter. The kind of fighter that doesn't appear very often. Ring intelligence, speed, power, & unpredictability. He was superior to Cal in just about every category. In his prime he would have a very good chance of beating all time greats like:

Hagler
Hearns
Leonard
Duran
Spinks
Monzon

I'm not sure if Cal could beat any of those fighters listed if matched skill for skill. You guys should ask the Ice Man John Scully about how Roy stacks up to the ATG's & how Cal would stack up as well.

[old68]

yes i have seen joe fight. his a superb fighter. he made kessler look like a worthles fighter when ever1 knows that kessler is an elite fighter.

the question is have you seen roy fight? a prime roy fight?? he was untouchable man. he literally toyed with toney and hopkins. *** all the excuses you can about the reason y hopkins and toney loss. he toyed with em. in his PRIME he was unstoppable and untouchable at 168 and 175.

Kessler is elite now?

[The Hammer]

Calzaghe was a harder puncher in his prime than he is now, and Roy Jones doesn't have the greatest chin.

Joe would have won by KO...

[Oasis_Lad]

thats coz ur a co.ck suckin bitach!! like seriously, ur a ***n tool. you actually thought jones was beatable?? u idiot. the only way you could have beat roy was if you were faster or fitter than him. his reflexes were so fast it was like a mongoose vs cobra. ill grade u a D for ***head.

Wow, Immanuel Kant step on down.

If you truly believe Jones was some unstoppable force then i feel sorry for you.

I'll grade your comeback P for piss-poor. I was going to show my compassion and grade it I for illiterate nonsense, but what's the use in grading ****?

[Addition]

Roy Jones without a doubt.