That was a GOOD STOPPAGE!!!

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bishop2006
    Pound For Pound
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Jan 2006
    • 5301
    • 175
    • 0
    • 12,214

    #11
    Originally posted by Kball15
    C'mon guys, Lee was practically out on his feet. He was throwing back, but he was gone. You dont recover from a round like that, where u take a beating for 2 minutes. And there was still about 45 seconds left, he was wobbly, he was gonna get hurt. u have to stop that fight. Wasn't a pleasing stoppage because he did throw back, but he was out of it.
    Lee has a ton of heart though. Vera too. And they put on a hell of a show. A freakin war, that was a terrific fight, reminded me a lot of Bika-Codrington.

    And, i would like to point out (and u can go back to one of the first LEE-VERA on ESPN2 threads to confirm this) that i predicted this upset here tonight so if one of you guys wants to send over some kind of medal or something...
    Similar to the guy in yours and my avatar Kelly Pavlik in the first Taylor fight,where he was getting hit with HUGE shots everywhere on his head,went down,got up and got wobbled very badly again,what happened..Pavlik went on to recover the next round,and won the fight,i know u dont like Lee because of the hype,but a blindman could see it was a terrible stoppage for someone who was winning every round,and didnt even touch the canvas,and was throwing back

    Comment

    • !! Shawn
      !! Shown
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Dec 2007
      • 9810
      • 670
      • 724
      • 31,455

      #12
      Originally posted by bishop2006
      Similar to the guy in yours and my avatar Kelly Pavlik in the first Taylor fight,where he was getting hit with HUGE shots everywhere on his head,went down,got up and got wobbled very badly again,what happened..Pavlik went on to recover the next round,and won the fight,i know u dont like Lee because of the hype,but a blindman could see it was a terrible stoppage for someone who was winning every round,and didnt even touch the canvas,and was throwing back
      That is a horrible comparison. Pavlik was actively blocking punches when he got up. Pavlik was not out on his feet, he was simply on wobbly legs.

      Lee was OUT on his feet. He looked like Tommy Hearns in the 14th round against Leonard.

      Comment

      • Njord777
        Archaic Pugilist
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • May 2006
        • 2509
        • 177
        • 9
        • 8,928

        #13
        Like I said:

        No. It wasn't a good stoppage. You can tell when a fighter starts getting smacked around the ring like Lee was that the referee is looking for an excuse to stop it. Vera landed a hard punch but, right as the referee stepped in, Lee was connecting with his own hard shot. You stop a fight when a fighter is no longer able to defend themselves. If Andy Lee was throwing a punch that goes out the window. Ten seconds earlier; good stoppage. Ten seconds later; probably a good stoppage. But in ten seconds a **** of a lot can happen- Lee could score a miracle K.O. or even get viciously knocked out. Looking out for a fighter is one thing; stopping it at a bad time is another. Sure, I think it would have been stopped eventually but at the time of the stoppage Lee was throwing a punch- so it was a bad stoppage. Saying the fight needed to be stopped is one thing; stopping it while the fighter is fighting back is another. Bad stoppage.

        Comment

        • Gareth Ivanovic
          Bale, Bale, Bale
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Mar 2007
          • 10113
          • 295
          • 597
          • 20,073

          #14
          Yeah I remember your prediction Kball. I thought you were out of your mind, but I guess not. I thought the stoppage was questionable for sure, at the same time Lee was taking huge shots and Manny seemed to accept the stoppage so I won't complain. Lee showed good heart, taking huge shots and still standing.

          Comment

          • MELLY-MEL...
            Broken, Beat, Scarred
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 11274
            • 1,059
            • 1,667
            • 33,296

            #15
            Iagree with the stoppage, and it will severely lessen the impact of the KO that was most likely happening shortly thereafter, and lee will be back to fight another day unbroken, and scarred by a ko.!

            Comment

            • Kball15
              HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Apr 2006
              • 15471
              • 491
              • 86
              • 22,680

              #16
              Originally posted by TheManchine
              On that basis they should've stopped the first Pavlik vs Taylor fight in the 2nd round.

              That was NOT a good stoppage even though Lee could've been put out in the next 5 seconds.

              Lee was up on the cards, still on his feet, throwing punches back.
              He did seem like he was out on his feet but he landed a punch, flush on Vera's chin.

              I guess I have a more 'old school' mentality regarding referee stoppages but I don't think the referee did a good job even if Lee and Steward said they are OK with it. It's just not right to stop it like that.
              i dont think anybody would have complained if they stopped Pavlik-Taylor 1 after that clubbing shot.

              But this is much different. Pavlik was down in round 2 after a very competitive round 1. Lee was just in a war for 6 rounds, and took an absolute thrashing for 2 full minutes.

              He was gone. I agree with you to some extent though, and i agree with the guy above who said it wasnt a good stoppage, but a JUSTIFIED stoppage. I agree with that. i think it was Devious who said that

              Comment

              • Njord777
                Archaic Pugilist
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • May 2006
                • 2509
                • 177
                • 9
                • 8,928

                #17
                See, everyone that is agreeing with the stoppage is taking it by the context of the round. I agree, Lee was getting smacked around. I agree, Vera was probably going to K.O. him. If the referee had stepped in over the course of the round while Andy was getting smacked around; good stoppage. If the referee had let Lee finish his weak little rally when he stopped it, and Vera just came back to stagger him further- that would have been a good stoppage. To pull a fighter who is in the middle of a punch off another man and stop the fight is ******, though. I'm the first one to look out for a boxer...but that was a bad stoppage.

                Comment

                • Kball15
                  HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Apr 2006
                  • 15471
                  • 491
                  • 86
                  • 22,680

                  #18
                  Originally posted by bishop2006
                  Similar to the guy in yours and my avatar Kelly Pavlik in the first Taylor fight,where he was getting hit with HUGE shots everywhere on his head,went down,got up and got wobbled very badly again,what happened..Pavlik went on to recover the next round,and won the fight,i know u dont like Lee because of the hype,but a blindman could see it was a terrible stoppage for someone who was winning every round,and didnt even touch the canvas,and was throwing back
                  i dont not like Lee, i think he's exciting, i just thought all along that he was overhyped and Stewards statements about him beating Pavlik were pretty frustrating.

                  But like i said right above, i agree with what all you guys are saying and stuff, but it was Justified IMO. If you'll watch again about 10-15 seconds before the stoppage Lee trys to go back to boxing and while he is stepping backwards his legs buckle on their own.

                  Thats when things get dangerous in there. Could the ref have let the fight go on for a few more seconds and see what happened??? Yea, but would have been worth it? thats the question u gotta ask urself. It might have been a big mistake to let Lee eat 1 or 2 more big shots.

                  Comment

                  • bishop2006
                    Pound For Pound
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Jan 2006
                    • 5301
                    • 175
                    • 0
                    • 12,214

                    #19
                    Originally posted by Kball15
                    i dont think anybody would have complained if they stopped Pavlik-Taylor 1 after that clubbing shot.

                    But this is much different. Pavlik was down in round 2 after a very competitive round 1. Lee was just in a war for 6 rounds, and took an absolute thrashing for 2 full minutes.

                    He was gone. I agree with you to some extent though, and i agree with the guy above who said it wasnt a good stoppage, but a JUSTIFIED stoppage. I agree with that. i think it was Devious who said that
                    It was an action fight,but Lee wasnt in a war,he was actually winning every round,at at 1 point reminded me of Cintron-Feliciano,where Vera was just taking huge shot after huge shot and walking thru them,it wasnt a close fight,i agree,Lee was taking huge punches in the round,but towards the stoppage,it looked like he was getting in better shape then he was two minutes before that

                    Comment

                    • Kball15
                      HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • Apr 2006
                      • 15471
                      • 491
                      • 86
                      • 22,680

                      #20
                      Originally posted by !! Shawn
                      That is a horrible comparison. Pavlik was actively blocking punches when he got up. Pavlik was not out on his feet, he was simply on wobbly legs.

                      Lee was OUT on his feet. He looked like Tommy Hearns in the 14th round against Leonard.
                      yeaaaaaa! it looked a lot like that.

                      That must have been a ****in nightmare for Emanuel Steward! lol. He always says in interviews that he HATES thinking/talking/watching that 14th round.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP