Calzaghe v James Toney at 168 who wins

[RichCCFC]

Both James Toney and Mikkel Kessler are tactical fighters, both of them lost to the best fighters of thier decade because of their superior hand speed and footwork.

[Dynamite Kid]

Both James Toney and Mikkel Kessler are tactical fighters, both of them lost to the best fighters of thier decade because of their superior hand speed and footwork.

Michael Nunn was pretty damn quick for a Middleweight ,still quick enough and good enough for Roy Jones to avoid

[Dynamite Kid]

u forget Michael Nunn knocked Sambu Kalambay Cleanout a guy who made Mike McCallum look like an average fighter ,Toney Knocked Nunn out

[sterling]

hm tough one but i pick toney by ko or joe by SD

[Dynamite Kid]

hm tough one but i pick toney by ko or joe by SD

LMAO

Toney aint Knocking Calzaghe out

[badnewsbrown]

toney at his best would have beat calzaghe up.

[Dynamite Kid]

made a poll on the fight get voting

shame on the ones who choose either fighter by KO

[Dynamite Kid]

i know Zag was not prime but he walked into some monster right hands from Reid & Eubank & more recently Kessler hit him wiht some corking right hands & uppercuts

If he steamed in like that against Toney he would get hit all night with Right hand

[Liaison]

Calzaghe...

Toney loved it when opponents wanted to get on the inside and slug it out. But Calzaghe also absolutely loved it when opponents wanted to get on the inside and slut it out. Joe had faster hands than Toney, and if anybody could stun Toney it was Calzaghe with his speed of hand.

Joe's a much faster starter than James, so those early rounds would be all his and he'd be able to keep range later on to keep a comfortable decision.

[J_CON]

Tony by Close Decision