Samuel Peter Vs. Vitali Klitschko. Who wins? (Now with poll)

[leff]

The big issue would also be ring-rust.

One can only hope that the height of Vitali prevents Peters rabbit-punching from having an effect.

Oh man I cant wait to see 'Dirty Peter' on the mat.

vit allways comes in shape, he is the type off guy that comes in shape and healthy ore dont come at all

[mECHsLAVE]

Very hard to predict. Vitali of 2003 stops Peter late. But who knows who this new Vitali is? Very hard to come off of a really long layoff into a fight with a guy as strong as Peter. I'd probably favor Vitali if he seems like he's in really good shape and in his old form. But who knows where Vitali's head's at and how serious a training camp he'll be able to have, being scared of injuries...

Hard to predict, but until I see different I have to go with Vitali.

[BattlingNelson]

Very hard to predict. Vitali of 2003 stops Peter late. But who knows who this new Vitali is? Very hard to come off of a really long layoff into a fight with a guy as strong as Peter. I'd probably favor Vitali if he seems like he's in really good shape and in his old form. But who knows where Vitali's head's at and how serious a training camp he'll be able to have, being scared of injuries...

Hard to predict, but until I see different I have to go with Vitali.

He probably will be in shape, but can he dust off the rust?

BTW he looked a little puffy to me.

[loui_ludwig]

I will go for Vitali for UD but this fight will not happen. Vitali will get hurt again in training and the fight will be cancel.

[BattlingNelson]

I will go for Vitali for UD but this fight will not happen. Vitali will get hurt again in training and the fight will be cancel.

He absolutely looked like he meant business.

[PBDS]

.....If Vitali were 100% healthy and he was not as inactive as he's been then I would be completly certain that he would destroy Peter. As it is I have my doubts. How can big Vit come back after so long and be effective immediately? Granted he stays in great shape, but will he be sharp and dominant like before? If he is somewhat sharp and still on his game he will crush Peter and leave him in a heap on the canvas.

[IZYAXS]

****. Dont wanna see it. And it is does happen, I hope Vitali loses. I thought the whole point was to unify the belts. If Vitali wins, this might hold back unification back years because him and Wladimir will never fight.

You are 100% correct.
Wladimir said it himself, he will never fight his brother. Who would? lol
If this fight does happen, we all need Peter's to win.
We need a Samuel Vs Wladimir undisputed unification fight.

[Guest]

If this was the Vitali that won the belt and defended it once then Vitali by KO no question IMO.

Now there are factors that have to be questioned, but that's all. It's all questions about Vitali (lay off, injuries, rust) and none about Sam.

[Thread Stealer]

The fight doesn't happen when Brittley pulls out with another injury.

[Enayze]

The fight doesn't happen when Brittley pulls out with another injury.

Ahhh yes Vitali's biggest fan has arrived.