Are people really this bad at scoring fights?

[Texanballer]

I am an Admin at fightjudge, i cant speak for everyone, but myself ive never had a lopsided scorecard. All of mine were almost always right unless it was a robbery. only one i ever screwed up on was taylor-pavlik 2, i had taylor winning 115-113

casamayor-santacruz i had 117-110 santacruz, i had it 117-111 calzaghe the dlh-mayweather and hopkins-wright i did not score

[dr.knoise]

I've been to a site called Fightjudge recently, and while it's a cool site where you can do scorecards I have seen some crazy scores out there.

Here are examples:

*115-113 for Kessler over Calzaghe
*118-110 for Oscar over Floyd
*120-109 for Bernard over Winky
*116-112 for Soto over Guzman


And then are the official judges who scored it for Casamayor over Santa Cruz and that idiot who scored it for Holyfield over Lewis.

Are people really this bad at scoring fights? I mean it's not that hard to screw up that many obvious rounds is it?

You must have seen Dave Murphy's scorecard:



After the fight, he claimed how much he hated Calzaghe.

[warp1432]

That's the person I was talking about.

The thing is, I chatted with him during Marquez-Vazquez 3 and he seemed like a pretty cool dude. How he got that score is beyond me though.

Also how did you paste other people's scorecards on here? I can only do mine.

[Texanballer]

That's the person I was talking about.

The thing is, I chatted with him during Marquez-Vazquez 3 and he seemed like a pretty cool dude. How he got that score is beyond me though.

Also how did you paste other people's scorecards on here? I can only do mine.

this was mine from calzaghe-kessler

[dr.knoise]

That's the person I was talking about.

The thing is, I chatted with him during Marquez-Vazquez 3 and he seemed like a pretty cool dude. How he got that score is beyond me though.

Also how did you paste other people's scorecards on here? I can only do mine.

You have to know their member number. I knew Dave's number.

Dave is a great guy. He's passionate though about the boxers he like and dislike, which affects his scores.

[Motofan]

Wow...some people just dont care how bad they look I guess. I understand they arent official judges, but what is the point of putting out there the fact that you are a ****** when it comes to scoring boxing? Nobody can defend those scores.

[warp1432]

this was mine from calzaghe-kessler

Round 12 to calzaghe? Really?

I think I had my scorecard 117-111 or 116-112. I can't remember.