Which names are better on your record?

[rj_ct]

Mikkel Kessler was regarded as a top 10 P4P fighter by many.

no ****ing way was kessler ever in a p4p top 10. not at all dude.

box rec's ratings suck just for the record.

[Degsy]

kswizzy99 never has any valid arguements at all. He trys to force his BS down everyones throat every time there is an arguement. Calzaghe is clearly better than Pavlik in every way including resumes so that's the arguement over.

He's French Canadian, they think differently to you and I. Imagine a Frenchman but without a yellow streak, twice as stubborn and three times as proud!!! Gallic Logic is an Oxymoron!!

I find him entertaining at times though, he's got an MMA backgroud so he's always gonna favour Bernard (appreciates the elbow strikes and headbuts) over the man from the Pays de Galles

[FloydFanatic]

oscar hatton oscar. 2 big all time greats.

[Crazylegs77]

Boxrec who compiles a 365 day record for each active fighter and than calculates it and spits out a ranking for each fighter and also with consideration on who they are scheduled to fight next, their top 3 fighers p4p according to this calculation are Hopkins, Vazquez and Mayweather in that order. Do you agree with this ranking?

What I like to do is take the fighters records of everyone they beat and factor in their average level of opposition..

For example
Floyd I think avg opponent has 26 wins 5 losses
Hatton 22 wins 8 losses

[-Swizzy-]

Okay you're only listing the fights they had since the beginning of last year (of course Calzaghe had fewer, he's 10 years older.) But using that same method, Floyd would drop completely off if he only fought DLH this year, which looks highly probable.

what does that got to do with calzaghe-pavlik? I never said that floyd deserves to stay atop the p4p list if he only fights dlh. If by the end of this year he only fights dlh than he doesn't deserve to be in the top 10 p4p I agree. the same goes for calzaghe, he doesn't deserve to be above pavlik on a p4p list right now.

[-Swizzy-]

He's French Canadian, they think differently to you and I. Imagine a Frenchman but without a yellow streak, twice as stubborn and three times as proud!!! Gallic Logic is an Oxymoron!!

I find him entertaining at times though, he's got an MMA backgroud so he's always gonna favour Bernard (appreciates the elbow strikes and headbuts) over the man from the Pays de Galles

lol, you funny.

[Motofan]

Write and Calzaghe, only because Joe is the best fighter of anyone mentioned.

[Pugilistic™]

wright, calzaghe