Dan Rafael's WW Rankings 2/18/08

[RL_GMA]

Your thoughts...

http://sports.espn.go.com/sports/boxing/columns/story?columnist=rafael_dan&id=3222461

[Guest]

I would have Clottey over Judah at this point. Judah hasn't won a significant fight in years. Everything else seems OK. He's right about Mayweather and DLH wanting no part of Cotto.

[Mozza]

Margarito should drop behind Mosley and Quintana.

[DrewWoodside]

He has marg at 20 overall, so Dan's a big Marg fan apparently

[Gareth Ivanovic]

I don't know about Margarito at number 3. I would put Mosley ahead of him and then I agree as well that Clottey should be ahead of Judah. Who really hasn't beaten a known name in a while.

[Silencers]

Clottey should be in front of Judah and Collazo, Margarito should drop behind Mosley and Quintana.

[MaFu MoFo]

MaFu's TOP WWs

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. (39-0)
2. Miguel Cotto (31-0)
3. Shane Mosley (44-5)
4. Kermit Cintron (29-1)
5. Carlos Quintana (25-1)
6. Paul Williams (33-1)
7. Antonio Margarito (35-5)
8. Zab Judah (36-5)
9. Joshua Clottey (33-2)
10. Luis Collazo (28-3)
In the bubble mix, Andre Berto (21-0)


I got to go to work, later Tonight, I may add my comments... peace!!!

[2501]

i dont trust anyone who's name cosist of 2 first names.

[RAESAAD]

I would have Clottey over Judah at this point. Judah hasn't won a significant fight in years. Everything else seems OK. He's right about Mayweather and DLH wanting no part of Cotto.

And Clottey above Collazo.....IMO....but I agree with everything you say.

[clemente]

why does everyone give clottey credit. he has not beaten anybody. he's tough and always gives a decent fight. but his toughest opponent was margarito, margarito fought like crap. then he beat diego corrales at 147lbs, diego was way too small to be fighting at that weight, in my opinion he shouldn't even be top ten. maybe put berto up there as a prospect.