All-time p4p top 10

[Technical_Skill]

When did I say that?

This is pretty close.

He has a case to be though.

Anyways, i dont see how you guys can call other members ****** then claim calzaghe could be Top 10 P4P OF ALL TIME.

Seriously, Rocky Balboa has more of a case than Calzaghe.

[msagrain]

Guys either post your all time list or shut up! Both Jones and Calzaghe are extremely overrated.

This is what we do on this site debate about fighters.

[GooGoo]

This is what we do on this site debate about fighters.

This is an all time P4P top 10 list, take your bitching to another thread and stop spamming this guys thread.

[Greatwhitehope]

No because b-hop has dodged joe time and time agen untill now.

Also joes and b-hops resume are about the same.

But he actually took on good opposition and then moved up a weight class.

B-Hop's resume is better by quite a lot imo. Calzaghe did beat Kessler, very impressive but other than that, meh.

All in all it's just opinion and yours is yours and mine is mine.

Got to admit though, B-hop's resume will look almost too good with Calzaghe's name on it under the W column.

[msagrain]

This is an all time P4P top 10 list, take your bitching to another thread and stop spamming this guys thread.

yes and we are debating about rjj or joe c at who would be higher on the list.

[RichCCFC]

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammed Ali
3. Sugar Ray Leonard
4. Joe Louis
5. Marvin Hagler
6. Willie Pep
7. Floyd Mayweather
8. Roberto Duran
9. Joe Calzaghe
10. Roy Jones Jr

[GooGoo]

yes and we are debating about rjj or joe c at who would be higher on the list.

Both don't belong in any top 10 P4P list.

[msagrain]

But he actually took on good opposition and then moved up a weight class.

B-Hop's resume is better by quite a lot imo. Calzaghe did beat Kessler, very impressive but other than that, meh.

All in all it's just opinion and yours is yours and mine is mine.

Got to admit though, B-hop's resume will look almost too good with Calzaghe's name on it under the W column.

Yes but he will not beat joe lol. i think b-hop has just had better opportunities to fight better fighter than joe.

[Allucard]

What are your top 10 p4p all-time?

here are mine

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Roy Jones Jr.
4. Sugar Ray Leonard
5. Marvin Hagler
6. Willie Pep
7. Roberto Duran
8. Sam Langford
9. Joe Louis
10. Ali

P4P list is to say "best fighter" not most acomplished. Keep that in mind when look at this. Also note Heavyweights have no business in P4P lists for obvious reason. If they did, you'd have to place a 7ft giant with a puch number one. It would be like saying Sammy Schilt is the best kickboxer in the world.

[Greatwhitehope]

This is an all time P4P top 10 list, take your bitching to another thread and stop spamming this guys thread.

Feeling left out? Is that what this is?
I'll argue with you if you want?