All-time p4p top 10

[Greatwhitehope]

if you can have rjj in the top 10 p4p listof all time you can certainly have joe c.

Not exactly, RJJ was dominant in quite a few weight classes and really dominated for a while.

Calzaghe is just Calzaghe.

[RichCCFC]

He has a case to be though.

[msagrain]

You sure mate? What the **** is this then?







Shocking.

i'd rather have joe c in the list than a drugey.

[msagrain]

Not exactly, RJJ was dominant in quite a few weight classes and really dominated for a while.

Calzaghe is just Calzaghe.

World titles in different weight classes is over rated. Try to be to top man in 1 weight class for over 10 years.

[Greatwhitehope]

World titles in different weight classes is over rated. Try to be to top man in 1 weight class for over 10 years.

He hasn't exactly beaten the best though has he.

If you want to look at it like that wouldn't Bernard Hopkins have a better case?

[RichCCFC]

Yeah, Joe Calzaghe didn't get KOed either. He beat a 7 years younger Mikkel Kessler while Jones got KOed by a crusty old Tarver.

[RichCCFC]

I have Joe at #9 P4P alltime

[msagrain]

He hasn't exactly beaten the best though has he.

If you want to look at it like that wouldn't Bernard Hopkins have a better case?

No because b-hop has dodged joe time and time agen untill now.

Also joes and b-hops resume are about the same.

[GooGoo]

Guys either post your all time list or shut up! Both Jones and Calzaghe are extremely overrated.

[GooGoo]

I have Joe at #9 P4P alltime

Morrade Hakkar > Joe Calzaghe