What boxing divisons should be added and taken away??

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jabsRstiff
    ! ! ! !
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Jun 2004
    • 8964
    • 498
    • 136
    • 16,167

    #31
    Originally posted by kswizzy99
    if you are replying to me than you didn't read my post properly. I said wipe out the 6(unbelievable number) divisions below 126(featherweight). I don't think its too much to ask for a 105 guy to gain weight and fight at 126.

    You obviously have never boxed, nor know very much about the game.

    Comment

    • flat1985
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Dec 2007
      • 3623
      • 79
      • 59
      • 12,950

      #32
      Originally posted by kswizzy99
      if you are replying to me than you didn't read my post properly. I said wipe out the 6(unbelievable number) divisions below 126(featherweight). I don't think its too much to ask for a 105 guy to gain weight and fight at 126.
      It is very hard for someone to jump from 105 - 126 infact

      Comment

      • -Swizzy-
        The Wolf
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Dec 2007
        • 8821
        • 431
        • 330
        • 661,075

        #33
        Originally posted by kswizzy99
        I say all the weight divisons under 126 should be dumped. and believe it or not, there are 6 divisions under 126. I think that is ridiculous. if you are 105, gain weight and fight in the 126 limit. there would be more talent and the 126 division would improve immensly.
        I say scrap super middleweight. talent is too divided as it is.
        I think there is a great need for a super heavyweight division cuz a 6'6 guy against a 6'0 guy is just ******. I can't say that I am with the dividing of the cruiserweight division cuz that would divide that talent in half and that would be terrible. I think someone who is 176 could easily gain weight and be 200. even in the light heavyweight weight division everyone is basically the same height as the cruiserweight guys.
        Infact, let me revise that. I think every second divison after featherweight should be eliminated as well. I did think about this carefully, and even if this were to happen, fighters would still be basically the same height anyway, and they wouldn't be jumping from divison to division as easily when they aren't doing so well in one division.

        these are the divisons with the potential top fighters in each in no real order:

        126 Featherweight
        Chris John
        Israel Vasquez
        Rafael Marquez
        Ivan Calderon

        135 Lightweight
        Juan Diaz
        Manny Pacquao
        Ricky Hatton
        Juan Manual Marquez
        Joan Guzman
        Paulie Malinaggi
        David Diaz
        Michael Katsidis

        145 Welterweight
        Floyd Mayweather
        Miguel Cotto
        Paul Williams
        Shane Mosley
        Antonio Margarito
        Junior Witter

        160 Middleweight
        Kelly Pavlik
        Winky Wright
        Oscar De La Hoya
        Vernon Forrest
        Jermaine Taylor
        Cory Spinks

        175 Light heavyweights
        Bernard Hopkins
        Joe Calzaghe
        Antonio Tarver
        Chad Dawson
        Glen Johnson
        Mikkel Kessler

        200 Cruiserweight
        Same as now

        235 Heavyweight
        Ruslan Chagaev
        Sultan Ibragimov
        Alexander Povetkin
        Eddie Chambers

        Unlimited Super Heavyweight
        Wladimir Klitchsko
        Samuel Peter<--he would probably lose 15 pounds and fight as a hw
        Nickolay Valuev
        Oleg Maskaev<----he would also prob fight as a hw

        every division would be stacked the way welterweight is now. saturday night pay-per-views would improve cuz there would be more great fights to watch. I think creating weight classes is detrimental to boxing with the exception of heavyweight cuz that weight class is just way to vast and needs to be divided.
        Last edited by -Swizzy-; 01-11-2008, 07:21 PM.

        Comment

        • KESSLER
          GOONER FOR LIFE
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • May 2007
          • 15487
          • 782
          • 716
          • 24,000

          #34
          Originally posted by kswizzy99
          Infact, let me revise that. I think every second divison after featherweight should be eliminated as well. I did think about this carefully, and even if this were to happen, fighters would still be basically the same height anyway, and they wouldn't be jumping from divison to division as easily when they aren't doing so well in one division.

          these are the divisons with the potential top fighters in each in no real order:

          126 Featherweight
          Chris John
          Israel Vasquez
          Rafael Marquez
          Ivan Calderon

          135 Lightweight
          Juan Diaz
          Manny Pacquao
          Juan Manual Marquez
          Joan Guzman
          David Diaz
          Michael Katsidis

          145 Welterweight
          Floyd Mayweather
          Miguel Cotto
          Ricky Hatton
          Paul Williams
          Shane Mosley
          Junior Witter
          Paulie Malinaggi
          Antonio Margarito

          160 Middleweight
          Kelly Pavlik
          Winky Wright
          Oscar De La Hoya
          Vernon Forrest
          Jermaine Taylor
          Cory Spinks

          175 Light heavyweights
          Bernard Hopkins
          Joe Calzaghe
          Antonio Tarver
          Chad Dawson
          Glen Johnson
          Mikkel Kessler

          200 Cruiserweight
          Same as now

          235 Heavyweight
          Ruslan Chagaev
          Sultan Ibragimov
          Alexander Povetkin
          Eddie Chambers

          Unlimited Supermiddleweight
          Wladimir Klitchsko
          Samuel Peter<--he would probably lose 15 pounds and fight as a hw
          Nickolay Valuev
          Oleg Maskaev<----he would also prob fight as a hw

          every division would be stacked the way welterweight is now. saturday night pay-per-views would improve cuz there would be more great fights to watch. I think creating weight classes is detrimental to boxing with the exception of heavyweight cuz that weight class is just way to vast and needs to be divided.
          Why do you have a dude posing in a dress in your sig?

          Comment

          • -Swizzy-
            The Wolf
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 8821
            • 431
            • 330
            • 661,075

            #35
            Originally posted by Young Money
            Why do you have a dude posing in a dress in your sig?
            thats laila ali. yes she has big legs, but she has a damn pretty face.

            Comment

            • -Swizzy-
              The Wolf
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Dec 2007
              • 8821
              • 431
              • 330
              • 661,075

              #36
              Originally posted by jabsRstiff
              You obviously have never boxed, nor know very much about the game.
              yes I know it would take alot for a guy at 105 to gain the weight plus he wouldn't have the reach or height to cut it in the featherweight division but really, under featherweight, nobody really cares about those divisions. I mean, how much money are those guys making? most of them are probably still poor. So what is the point of having those divisions?

              Comment

              • flat1985
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Dec 2007
                • 3623
                • 79
                • 59
                • 12,950

                #37
                Originally posted by kswizzy99
                yes I know it would take alot for a guy at 105 to gain the weight plus he wouldn't have the reach or height to cut it in the featherweight division but really, under featherweight, nobody really cares about those divisions. I mean, how much money are those guys making? most of them are probably still poor. So what is the point of having those divisions?
                I think poor is a bit much

                Comment

                • -Swizzy-
                  The Wolf
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 8821
                  • 431
                  • 330
                  • 661,075

                  #38
                  who would pay to see niida vs condes or donaire vs naito or martin castillo vs munoz. Those are the top 2 fighters in some of the divisons below featherweight. i don't think that is even a minimul draw.

                  Comment

                  • flat1985
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Dec 2007
                    • 3623
                    • 79
                    • 59
                    • 12,950

                    #39
                    Originally posted by kswizzy99
                    who would pay to see niida vs condes or donaire vs naito or martin castillo vs munoz. Those are the top 2 fighters in some of the divisons below featherweight. i don't think that is even a minimul draw.
                    There is some good fighters in the little divisions , You get some good wars and they tend to have better stamina, Fair play though each to are own

                    Comment

                    • -Swizzy-
                      The Wolf
                      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 8821
                      • 431
                      • 330
                      • 661,075

                      #40
                      Originally posted by flat1985
                      There is some good fighters in the little divisions , You get some good wars and they tend to have better stamina, Fair play though each to are own
                      yeah I guess. maybe featherweight at 125 and a flyweight at 116 should be created. I still think making a division for every 3 pounds is insane. It would be for the benefit for those fighters cuz they would have bigger fights for more money if there were less divisions below featherweight. I know the lower you go in weight, the percentage increases for every pound difference like 124 to 123 is bigger than 250-249 but I still can't buy that. My nephew who is 40 pounds has no problem taking down 50 pound kids. Less weight divisions is better for the sport of boxing.
                      Last edited by -Swizzy-; 01-07-2008, 03:37 PM.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP