Who is the worst fighter with a belt?

[-Swizzy-]

I'm still laughing over people putting Casa in there. ****, I was laughing BEFORE Katsidis.....

yeah I know. out of all the title holders casa was the one everyone was picking on. that was ridiculous.

[ElGranLuchador]

yeah I know. out of all the title holders casa was the one everyone was picking on. that was ridiculous.

casa shouldnt be a champ he lost clearly to santacruz thats why everyone was dissing him

[-Swizzy-]

casa shouldnt be a champ he lost clearly to santacruz thats why everyone was dissing him

well the question wasn't about who is deserving or not, it was who is the worst title holder skillwise. whether or not you think he is deserving or not is irrelevant. do you think Firat, Garay are better boxers cuz they deserve their titles more?

[Fox McCloud]

well the question was about who is deserving or not, it was who is the worst title holder skillwise. whether or not you think he is deserving or not is irrelevant. do you think Firat, Garay are better boxers cuz they deserve their titles more?

I mean, Casamayor did lose every round to an uncoordinated unknown and got knocked down. He looked slow, he looked like he had no timing, he looked like he had lost all of his power.

I can see where people were coming from when they thought that Joel Casamayor was done for in the sport.

[deevel79]

He's no longer an active fighter, but i think Baldomir was the worst fighter to ever hold a title.

[Mr. Ryan]

nate campbell
malignaggi
aj banal soon after he beats up that bum

If Nate Campbell is the worst fighter with a belt, what does that say about Juan Diaz?

[Fox McCloud]

He's no longer an active fighter, but i think Baldomir was the worst fighter to ever hold a title.

Big surprise.

[Mr. Ryan]

I didn't say he was a bad fighter because he wasn't a big star.

I just know he has a bunch of losses (a lot were early in his career).
Literally no one on this board picked him to beat Spinks.
A lot of people said that Spinks outboxed him fairly handily, but didn't get the decision.

Those are the ingredients of an underachiever unjustly having a belt, which would make him a decent candidate for worst fighter with a belt IMO.

Unjustly? Even Cory Spinks admits he lost. If a guy can go out there and give his best effort and be declared the winner, I don't think its unjust for him to be

Underachiever? Could it be that he's an overachiever who hung around forever by winning fights when he needed to, and gave it all he had when it mattered?

Verno Phillips is one of those tough veterans that you can't overlook because on any given night he can beat you.

[Fox McCloud]

Unjustly? Even Cory Spinks admits he lost. If a guy can go out there and give his best effort and be declared the winner, I don't think its unjust for him to be

Underachiever? Could it be that he's an overachiever who hung around forever by winning fights when he needed to, and gave it all he had when it mattered?

Verno Phillips is one of those tough veterans that you can't overlook because on any given night he can beat you.

Like I said, I've never seen him.

I just said in my first post that no one picked him, and a lot of people didn't agree with the decision.

Scratch it if it's wrong.

[ElGranLuchador]

If Nate Campbell is the worst fighter with a belt, what does that say about Juan Diaz?

diaz is not a champ
imo diaz wins in a rematch he deserves a rematch but don king knows better and its not letting it happen