What will it take?

[RAESAAD]

Cotto and Williams and he's there in my eyes......Maybe a trilogy with Cotto?Now that would be awesome for both guys careers.

[Jim Jeffries]

I am impressed with Floyd's career so far, and I am impressed with his skills as a boxer, especially his defence. But he hasn't done anything that hasn't been done before by Hearns, DLH, Toney, and more. If he retires right now, he certainly makes it into the HOF, and he is already on a lot of people's top 50 atg lists. He at least needs to unify a single division to be in contention for top 10 ATG.

[GearsOfWar]

for him to fight the best welterweights which he hasn't yet. Cotto, Williams, Margarito, and even Cintron. But the two best on that list are probably cotto and williams.

[BodyHead Banger]

Somehow score a KO over Cotto and/or Williams.

[GearsOfWar]

Somehow score a KO over Cotto and/or Williams.

Yeah right, those two aren't small at all. Hattons a small guy, theres no real surprise in Mayweather koing Hatton

[AntonTheMeh]

floyd is all ready an all timer,wins over cotto and williams and a middleweight champ will only determine where.i think he's top 25.if he beats cotto and williams he's top 15 if he wins a middleweight title he'll be 2 in my book no ****ing lie.

[BmoreBrawler]

as "an ATG"= too vague. Right now he is maybe top 40-30 all time.

[passey]

Nothing. It's clear PBF has already reached that level.

[GranTorino]

he needs to do i lot more in my eyes

I have no idea what "i lot" means, but my opinion of him went through the roof when he put my man Ricky down.