Is Floyd An ATG?

[tills9191]

Ok,sometimes I tend to think he's one of the most gifted fighters ever.
Would you guys agree he should be an ATG, or is it too early to put a label on him just yet?

[boxing_pundit85]

Ok,sometimes I tend to think he's one of the most gifted fighters ever.
Would you guys agree he should be an ATG, or is it too early to put a label on him just yet?

talent wise yes, but i think one or two more great wins would erase any doubt

[tills9191]

talent wise yes, but i think one or two more great wins would erase any doubt

Let's hope he will fight Cotto in the near future, and reinforce his greatness.

[C.Y.]

yeah he is an ATG
he beat the best in his era
and 6 legit belt in 5 different weight classes
he's not the goat or anything
but he is an ATG

[HotSizzle]

No doubt he's an ATG

[Verstyle]

I can agree with that now.

[Breakbeat]

That performance was an ATG from a ATG


Hatton =

[shawn_]

I can agree with that now.

Im flabbergasted that people are giving Floyd so much credit for a mediocre performance against little Ricky Hatton, whom he should not have been fighting in the first place.

If anything, tonights fight set Floyd back in his quest for ATG status.

[tills9191]

Im flabbergasted that people are giving Floyd so much credit for a mediocre performance against little Ricky Hatton, whom he should not have been fighting in the first place.

If anything, tonights fight set Floyd back in his quest for ATG status.

does any1 agree with this?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Im flabbergasted that people are giving Floyd so much credit for a mediocre performance against little Ricky Hatton, whom he should not have been fighting in the first place.

If anything, tonights fight set Floyd back in his quest for ATG status.

It gave him worldwide status... which a fight vs. Cotto et al would NOT have done.