Updated BoxingScene Pound-For-Pound List

[Dorian]

why isn't Gatti in the top 3???
horrible list

[wengz2002]

Why is Calderon in the Top Ten??? Are you joking?
I don't like fighters who always depend on the judges!!!
We know many judges are out of this world~ Scum...

I thought Esquer won in his last fight~

[Jim Jeffries]

Easily Floyd is #1.

Floyd has more wins against fighters in or near their prime than any other active fighter.

Do you really think Oscar is near his prime?

[crold1]

Wengz: That's fine; personally, I think he does amazing work for a guy without power and he has the balls to play out of the pocket too.

[MikeTysonJr]

Pac Man Deserves The #1 Spot Alone his Resume is 10X better and he only fights the best!

[VIVA MEXICO!!!]

this is a good p4p.

[crold1]

His resume is not 10X better. That's hyperbole. I have all the respect in the world for Pac and had him #1 for a while but he and Floyd, accomplishment wise are neck and neck so in a year when Pac didn't test himself even a little Floyd gets the credit. I love Cal too but this is still really a two-man race. The only man ever to win the legit Fly and Feather crowns v. the Only Guy to win the legit crowns at 30 and 47 with 35 thrown in? Great race.

Thanks Viva.

[MikeTysonJr]

His resume is much better then floyds it's not even an argument imo.

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Strange how Kessler hasn't even beaten a top 5 Super-middleweight yet he is higher than Hatton who beat a #3 p4p fighter. Hatton ain't a top 10 p4p fighter anymore but he's higher than Kessler.

[pbftxrs316]

His resume is much better then floyds it's not even an argument imo.

and that's why it's your opinion. he's not better than floyd because if you put them in a ring together at any weight, especially 130-140, he would be killed by floyd, and most agree with this. now, floy dis still undefeated and the most skillful fighter in boxing today, bar none. he has 0 losses and manny has 3 or 4, i lost count, but i look at skillwise, and manny couldn't lace floyd's shoes if floyd showed him how. his resume may consist of big names but he has lost to some of them and had a draw with a guy he knocked down 3 times in the first round, hello. let's see how he does against him next year, before we talk about pacman again, okay little one.