Updated BoxingScene Pound-For-Pound List

[-Hyperion-]

Disagree and I'm not much of a fan of his. I just respect the game it takes to be that good with no pop at all.

a top p4p fighter shouldnt have a life and death struggle with ronald barrera...but maybe im the only one who remembers that fight....(also he looked bad against esquer and went down with one punch vs cazares, ivans been looking old his last 3 fights...)

[Primal Instinx]

Bro this list makes no sense:

Tie-1) Floyd Mayweather & Manny Pacquiao
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Israel Vasquez
5) Ivan Calderon
6) Rafael Marquez
7) Bernard Hopkins
8) Juan Manuel Marquez
9) Mikkel Kessler
10) Miguel Cotto

How the hell is Mikkel Kessler over Cotto if he just got whooped and Cotto has beaten Judah and Mosley. Marquez just got his chops handed to him by Vasquez so why is he so far up on the list? Ivan Calderon that far up is also absurd. I agree with the top 3 guys with Manny at #2. But disagree with the rest of the list.

[boxer2k5]

that has to be the worse P4P ranks i ever seen. kessler? pac n floyd tied?

[-Hyperion-]

i also criticized the list but you guys need to read, thats the old list, the new list is below...and i still dont agree with it, but at least floyd is #1 in that one...

[Xcel]

Easily Floyd is #1.

Floyd has more wins against fighters in or near their prime than any other active fighter.

[crold1]

LOL at people who can't read where it says "previous list on September 16"...the new list is, as noted, below. I'm all for disagreement....just disagree with the right list.

[AntonTheMeh]

mufuqas need to read

good list.

[-Hyperion-]

mufuqas need to read

good list.

especially ivan "ovearrated as all ****" calderon, right ANTONIM???

[seantrader2001]

Jackass!!!

Let's get serious, Floyd Mayweather is the best fighter in the world... When you look at his constellation of skills and mental attitude it is not even close.. Manny is fun to watch but he is pure physicality and power... Floyd embodies the " Sweet Science" you clowns.....

[TheHammerJones]

I think cotto should be in the top 5 pound for pound. Bernard should not be, he prove that against Winky Wright.