Better record @ 130 Sinclair or Pacquiao?

[Sin City]

Marco Antonio Barrera (2)
Erik Morales (2)
Juan Manuel Marquez (draw)
Oscar Larios



Sinclair:
Genaro Hernandez
Angel Manfredy
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez


Who has the better resume in the division?? Vote.





I'm curious as to why Mayweather never fought Morales or Barrera. They would have been some interesting fights.

[AntonTheMeh]

I'm curious as to why Mayweather never fought Morales or Barrera. They would have been some interesting fights.

i made a thread about this about a week ago.i wondered too.o

[Sin City]

i made a thread about this about a week ago.i wondered too.o

My bad I didn't catch the thread.

So what was the main conlusion??

[eazy_mas]

it preet hard to tell because pac faced Morales and Barrera when they are out of there prime.


As for Marquez he faced him at FW and not SFW not sure.

[GTL]

ima go with pacman. even tho floyd is the better fighters..
on another note, i have no ****in clue why DLH wants to fight a tinier man.. when i heard that.. i was like wow, i lost all respect for dlh was a fighter

[ThaHorseman]

This poll is misleading. Pac only beat Barrera once at 130 and his fight with JMM was also at 126. Pac's resume at 130 includes wins over Barrera once, Morales twice, Soliis, Larios and Velasquez. Also, it was Larios' first and only fight at 130. He moved up 2 divisions for the fight.

[AntonTheMeh]

My bad I didn't catch the thread.

So what was the main conlusion??

nah it's cool.
and whoever voted floyd is a nuthugger of epic proportions.

[Sin City]

So far it's Pacquiao five to one.. He does have the better names in the weightclass but his two biggest wins are against fighters past their prime.

[ThaHorseman]

nah it's cool.
and whoever voted floyd is a nuthugger of epic proportions.

Not a nuthugger, I just don't feel an old Barrera, an old Morales and a small Larios is better than Corrales, Chavez, Hernandez x 2 and Manfredy. As I said above, this poll leads you to believe that Pac did things he didn't.

[JoartCC]

So far it's Pacquiao five to one.. He does have the better names in the weightclass but his two biggest wins are against fighters past their prime.

Excuses once again.

He beat MAB and Morales.

Period.

Excuses take backseat.

Fake Floyd has of course... no excuses also.

Lack a lot of elite names in his resume.

Of course he's a duck.