Hatton Doesn't Belong in the Top 10 P4P

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jim Jeffries
    rugged individualist
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 20740
    • 1,376
    • 2,868
    • 54,838

    #31
    Originally posted by BodyW8
    is it whites you hate sin, or just brits?
    No kidding, pretty tough to hate Calzaghe as well.

    Comment

    • BodyW8
      Banned
      • Jun 2007
      • 184
      • 22
      • 13
      • 254

      #32
      Yeah, I mean, as much as I think the Hatton being "overrated" arguments are bull**** but with a few points which could be argued, Calzaghe haters are just plain ****** after his last 4 fights.

      Comment

      • Floydko1
        Undisputed King
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • Apr 2006
        • 416
        • 14
        • 0
        • 6,721

        #33
        I think this post has alot to do with ppls locations in the world the guy with the disrespect for hatton & calzaghe is a total fool i bet if hatton and calzaghe where american calzaghe would be the pound4pound number1 in the world by now and hatton would be top 5 easy but just because america ant controlin **** all theirs all the haters out their i dont care where boxers are from just enjoy their skills and shut da *** UP,

        Comment

        • Floydko1
          Undisputed King
          Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
          • Apr 2006
          • 416
          • 14
          • 0
          • 6,721

          #34
          Calzaghes just taken out Kessler, theirs no middleweight,supermiddleweight,light heavy on the planet who would have beat kessler, hopkins would have been on his ass from some off thos kessler shots

          Comment

          • Unseen
            People Call Me Crazy
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jun 2007
            • 1897
            • 71
            • 14
            • 8,439

            #35
            Originally posted by $iN
            -Before Tszyu, he beat no one of note.

            -He beat an over the hill Tszyu who retired after the fight. Not only was Tszyu old, he was coming off of some major injuries and had fought a handful of rounds in 3 years. This is his best win clearly, but far from impressive considering Tszyu's age, health, activity, and fight location.

            -He followed up the win over Tszyu by beating Carlos Maussa, likely the worst beltholder in the history of the 140 lb. division. Maussa is so terrible he has gone on to lose to a journeyman coming off a 5 year layoff and then got knocked out in 1 round by a prospect. This is particularly embarrassing for Hatton when you consider that he struggled for 9 rounds with Maussa before finally ending the fight.

            -Hatton moved up to welterweight and received a gift decision against Luis Collazo. Hatton struggled the entire fight and was out on his feet in the final round.

            -Hatton returned to 140 to hit and hug his way to a win over a prospect Juan Urango. Why is a world champion still fighting prospects with 19 fights?

            -He followed that win by beating another over the hill name Jose Luis Castillo. Anyone who knows anything about boxing could see from the start of the first round that this version of Castillo clearly was damaged goods and nowhere near the fighter that fought an epic with Chico Corrales or gave Mayweather all he could handle 5 years earlier.


            Hatton has been fed nothing more than a steady diet of handpicked opponents through 43 fights and he is now cashing on his popularity with a Mayweather fight. Hatton belongs nowhere near the P4P and he will be exposed as merely an average fighter on December 8th...

            that is why most writers and boxing critics have him as p4p top 10. maybe they are wrong about mayweather too.

            Comment

            • $iN
              #1 Post 4 Post
              • Aug 2007
              • 182
              • 30
              • 3
              • 6,228

              #36
              Hatton has been handpicking opponents for years. This is his first real step up. And 2 fights doesn't make up for years of Calzaghe ducking and handpicking opponents as well. I'd give him more credit for any of his big wins if there weren't all in his hometown...

              Comment

              • C'MONMANG'
                Banned
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Oct 2007
                • 7002
                • 172
                • 21
                • 7,389

                #37
                Originally posted by $iN
                Hatton has been handpicking opponents for years. This is his first real step up. And 2 fights doesn't make up for years of Calzaghe ducking and handpicking opponents as well. I'd give him more credit for any of his big wins if there weren't all in his hometown...

                okay, let me get this staright. Hatton fought Kostya the ring champ at 140.

                and Floyd fought GAtti.. but HATTON is handpicking?

                you're cute sin.

                Comment

                • Unseen
                  People Call Me Crazy
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2007
                  • 1897
                  • 71
                  • 14
                  • 8,439

                  #38
                  Originally posted by $iN
                  Hatton has been handpicking opponents for years. This is his first real step up. And 2 fights doesn't make up for years of Calzaghe ducking and handpicking opponents as well. I'd give him more credit for any of his big wins if there weren't all in his hometown...
                  so if all the writers think hatton is p4p top 10 then are they wrong that floyld is p4p 1?

                  calz fought in his hometown. so what?

                  sometimes a fighter fights where and who his promtoer chooses.

                  Comment

                  • sonofisis
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2005
                    • 3241
                    • 233
                    • 78
                    • 9,871

                    #39
                    Originally posted by $iN
                    Hatton Doesn't Belong in the Top 10 P4P
                    Don't worry. On Dec. 9th, he won't be.

                    Comment

                    • Jim Jeffries
                      rugged individualist
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Oct 2007
                      • 20740
                      • 1,376
                      • 2,868
                      • 54,838

                      #40
                      Originally posted by sonofisis
                      Don't worry. On Dec. 9th, he won't be.
                      So losing to the #1 p4p knocks you out of the top 10? Explain that one to me. And how come Winky was still in the top 10 after losing to Hopkins, who wasn't even #1?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP