Antonio Margarito's Comeback Plan is to Fight Retreads?

[Fox McCloud]

Castillo has a win over Floyd

Let me check the scores:

Fight 1: Anek Hongtongkam 116-111, John Keane 115-111, Jerry Roth 115-111, all for Mayweather Jr.

Fight 2: Ken Morita 115-113, Larry O'Connell 116-113, Daniel Van de Wiele 115-113, all for Mayweather Jr.

Sounds like you are really holding your own in this thread.

You've managed to start saying that Castillo was less shot than De La Hoya in their respective bouts against Hatton and Mayweather Jr. Well done.

Round of applause for this genius, everyone please.

[C'MONMANG']

Maybe Castillo should not be as active, he sure could use the brain cells later on...Oscar was coming off KOing a titleholder in Mayorga in a higher weight class than Floyd fought...Castillo is coming off winning a controversial split decision against a contender who struggled with a guy that Cotto brutalized and after being KOd in 4 rounds, both fights to guys in a lower weight class than Margarito...Oscar may be older, but does that matter? Calzaghe is 36 and Vargas 29, who would win at 168?

And last I checked Floyd beat Castillo twice...at 135 and 5 years ago. How does this justify Margarito fighting him?

oscar is not active, not even a fighter anymore. a promoter..

[Fox McCloud]

is that why he says he wont fight Cotto " No paper in it baby"..

c'monmang' says: Floyd has no interest in fighting any of the top welters.

DWiens421 says: He has said that he wants to fight the winner of Cintron-Williams.

c'monmang' stutters for a bit, and then says: he wont fight Cotto!

So in your estimation, Cintron and Williams are not top welterweights?

No really, everyone is actually respecting your take on boxing a whole lot more with every post you make.

[Super_Lightweight]

That's what it seems like to me. Antonio Margarito's struggle right now is to prove that he is more than an ordinary fighter. He's looking to prove that by fighting an ancient Golden Johnson and a worn-out Jose Luis Castillo? Give me a break.

Castillo is a lightweight coming off a KO loss at 140, and now Margarito wants him at 147. What bull****. Until Margarito decides to step up in class where its dangerous, I'm not going to acknowledge him as a top contender.

Then please, tell us what other fighters want to fight Margarito, and which ones give him more 'credibility'.

Margarito is a top contender at 147 whether anyone likes it or not.

[C'MONMANG']

c'monmang' says: Floyd has no interest in fighting any of the top welters.

DWiens421 says: He has said that he wants to fight the winner of Cintron-Williams.

c'monmang' stutters for a bit, and then says: he wont fight Cotto!

So in your estimation, Cintron and Williams are not top welterweights?

No really, everyone is actually respecting your take on boxing a whole lot more with every post you make.

i could care less. Floyds actions show he doesnt want the tougest fight, or to fight the most deserved challenger.. and in THIS case it's Cotto..

its sad really

[tito yuca]

i could care less. Floyds actions show he doesnt want the tougest fight, or to fight the most deserved challenger.. and in THIS case it's Cotto..

its sad really

I'm not even gonna address this because it's another topic, but answer me this - is Castillo the "toughest fight" or the "most deserved challenger" for Margarito?

[Mike Tyson77]

i could care less. Floyds actions show he doesnt want the tougest fight, or to fight the most deserved challenger.. and in THIS case it's Cotto..

its sad really

Do you not know that Floyd is fighting Ricky Hatton??? Hatton is a top 10 P4P fighter.

[Fox McCloud]

i could care less. Floyds actions show he doesnt want the tougest fight, or to fight the most deserved challenger.. and in THIS case it's Cotto..

its sad really

So there is only one fight for Floyd to make... with Cotto right?

And Floyd was supposed to know this before Cotto eeked out a close decision over Mosley, which has now validated him as the best fighter at 147 besides Mayweather.

Before the Mosley bout, it was a pretty close race with Cintron, Cotto and Williams.

Floyd hasn't had a chance to make a fight with someone after the Hatton fight, because... well... the Hatton fight hasn't happened yet.

[tito yuca]

Let me check the scores:

Fight 1: Anek Hongtongkam 116-111, John Keane 115-111, Jerry Roth 115-111, all for Mayweather Jr.

Fight 2: Ken Morita 115-113, Larry O'Connell 116-113, Daniel Van de Wiele 115-113, all for Mayweather Jr.

Sounds like you are really holding your own in this thread.

You've managed to start saying that Castillo was less shot than De La Hoya in their respective bouts against Hatton and Mayweather Jr. Well done.

Round of applause for this genius, everyone please.

HAHAHA, one of the funniest posts I've ever seen here.

[niceguy45]

that proves nothing, i'd rather see a rematch margarito vs clottey,
it will prove a lot more to the viewing public