Is SRL a Top 5 All Time Great?

[Sweet Pete]

1) Ray Robinson

2) Muhammad Ali

3) Henry Armstrong

4) Ray Leonard

5) Pernell Whittaker

What do you base your rankings on? Resume? If so it needs a good re-thinking. Head to head? If so you could make arguments, but head to head is more subjective.

[BiggyGuns91]

1) Ray Robinson

2) Muhammad Ali

3) Henry Armstrong

4) Ray Leonard

5) Pernell Whittaker

****...we almost have the same list

[Rane-Ex54]

I can understand him being in peoples favorite fighter, but all time greatest??!?!?!?

[K-Nan]

What do you base your rankings on? Resume? If so it needs a good re-thinking. Head to head? If so you could make arguments, but head to head is more subjective.

A combination of head to head and resume. Level of comp, skill, and record all get factored in there.

And this is my P4P list, not favorite list.

[Sweet Pete]

A combination of head to head and resume. Level of comp, skill, and record all get factored in there.

And this is my P4P list, not favorite list.

So I assume you do not rate old timers very highly?

[Jim Jeffries]

ATG, absolutely. Top 5, no way, not enough fights. Period.

[MAXWELL_]

Not top 5, but top 10.

yeah... actually i got him at 11.

[Jim_Davis]

w00T dA ****KKKKKKHHHHHHHHHH PRITTY BOI FLOYD WOULDA KO'D HIZ AZZ IN DA SECAND ROUND W00T BIATCH W000000000TtT

[Sweet Pete]

yeah... actually i got him at 11.

#9 for me.

Mind if I see your list?

Here's mine

1. Ray Robinson
2. Harry Greb
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Muhammad Ali
5. Sam Langford
6. Ezzard Charles
7. Barney Ross
8. Roberto Duran
9. Ray Leonard
10. Pernell Whitaker

[Sweet Pete]

w00T dA ****KKKKKKHHHHHHHHHH PRITTY BOI FLOYD WOULDA KO'D HIZ AZZ IN DA SECAND ROUND W00T BIATCH W000000000TtT

So are you kidding or have you actually survived for 4,000 posts posting like that?