Freddie Roach vs. Manny Steward

[STEELHEAD]

manny is getting on my nerves more and more.the instructions he was giving in cintrons corner was so shallow. and now i look back when he was with the dimm taylor and wonder. its like he don't put enough effort into it.
and roach. i dont know, he must talk with his eyes because i dont hear much advise coming out of him when he's in the corner. okay,okay,okay.

[kasangga]

You seriously know nothing about boxing if you pick Roach over Steward.

You seriously know very little about boxing, based on your remark.
Take a look at the poll results.

[ELPacman]

It depends where your going with this. Either on how they are as a trainer or their accomplishments as a trainer. Manny of course has more accomplishments and goes way back. But sometimes as mentioned, he does try changing too much in a fighter and ends up taking away what made the fighter great to begin with. Freddy lets his fighter do what he wants, just improves his game rather than change it. This is a big issue really because you shouldn't change something that ain't broke. While it has worked in some cases for Steward, there has been many it hasn't.

[Slotff]

Steward UD12 116-112, 117-111, 118-110 Roach

[THe TRiNiTY]

Steward.. Though Roach is a very good trainer in his own right.

[Addison]

I had to check on this poll.. At one point Steward was way ahead.

[Left Hook Tua]

I think Manny is a better trainer. Roach is too relaxed sometimes and just lets the guy do whatever he wants, when he should be giving him directions.

sometimes relaxed is good.

sometimes when you're all pumped up you don't need some guy yelling at you when you're trying to rest.

you want a floyd mayweather sr. cursing at you when you're trying to catch a breather in between tough rounds?

where's buddy mcgirt in this poll? buddy is a solid trainer.

[KESSLER]

Roach by KO ... oh wait. better trainer.

I'd have to say Steward.

[Silencers]

Manny Steward is the better trainer of the two.

[Left Hook Tua]

Steward UD12 116-112, 117-111, 118-110 Roach

must be the johnson-dawson judges? when they fill out that scorecard? friday morning like with the fight?