If Hatton beats Mayweather ....

[AntonTheMeh]

Having Cotto that high already is a joke. Pavlik KO's Miranda and an unbeaten world champion in Taylor and doesn't make your list. but Cotto KO's a troubled Judah and ONLY JUST decisions a 36yr old Mosley and you have him at 4th??

This is how my list would look if Hatton won...

1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Joe Calzaghe
3) Floyd Mayweather Jr
4) Bernard Hopkins
5) Ricky Hatton
6) JMM
7) Israel Vazquez
8) Winky Wright
9) Rafael Marquez
10) Kelly Pavlik

I HAVE JOE C AT ONE,BUT BY YOUR LOGIC WHY IS HE 2?

[K-Nan]

I HAVE JOE C AT ONE,BUT BY YOUR LOGIC WHY IS HE 2?

Apparently Pacquiao has betterrecent performances.

[Tuggers1986]

I HAVE JOE C AT ONE,BUT BY YOUR LOGIC WHY IS HE 2?

Yeah, id agree actually. I just cant move him down when he aint lost. Although Calzaghes win over Kessler was enough for him to take over.

You're right.

[AntonTheMeh]

Apparently Pacquiao has betterrecent performances.

RICKY AND COTTO ARE EVEN FOR ME.I DON'T SEE MUCH OF A DIFFERENCE IN EACHES RESUME

[K-Nan]

RICKY AND COTTO ARE EVEN FOR ME.I DON'T SEE MUCH OF A DIFFERENCE IN EACHES RESUME

I know I wasn't the only one who saw the JLC fight as an easy task.

[-Hyperion-]

Apparently Pacquiao has betterrecent performances.

ISNT IT SICKENING HOW HE GOT TO THE #2 spot???....

he beats Barrera and he suddenly is #5....then he barely draws with Marquez..then he loses to coming off a loss recently dethroned off the top 4 p4p erik morales and only gets down 1 place in the list.....then he beats morales coming off the raheem loss(2005's upset of the year) and they put him at #3!!!!!!!!!!!and then he takes a totally unnecesary fight against a guy who's lost 3 of his last 4 who cant make the weight and he gets #2 and #1 to some people??????WTF is up with that....

[Pugilistic™]

should either be 3 or 4

[Rane-Ex54]

Come On Ya'll If Hatton beats flyod convincingly, he will be P4P #1

[El Jesus]

A P4P list is just a marketing tool to help American promoters to sell American based boxers,only reason Calzaghe is on it is because Lacy was hyped to the max and when he lost so so badly they had no choice but to put Calzaghe there.I think Hatton would be put at number 1 or 2 if he beat Mayweather as he is on DeLaHoyas books now.

thats ******, non americans have been on the p4p list for years, just because it so happens to be that most of the best boxers in the world have hailed from mexico, the USA and puerto rico doesnt mean it excludes everyone else.