Is it Fair to rank Margarito over P. Williams???

[King Koopa]

This issue will go up in flames if Kermit Cintron beats Paul Williams, then what??? At least, Cintron has spoken several times about fighting Margarito again. To be honest with you I would love to see the winner of Cintron-Williams to fight Margarito. Let Cotto KO DLH or MayWeather.

Yeah, that's a dilemna...

[Verstyle]

Wow,the thread starter has to be kidding. This is what makes Boxingscene 'special' sometimes.

[crillz]

it would be highly unfair to rank someone Paul beat higher than him, Paul is about to fight the biggest Puerto Rican threat at WW besides Miguel Cotto, a new and improved Kermit Cintron, the guy I call the Wladimir Klitschko of the WW's due to him NOW using his tools and pacing his power, coincedentally it just so happens to be that Emmanuel Steward grabbed them both up and fixed them, literally.. Margarito needs to chase either a De La Hoya fight or a Judah fight, all the other good names are already taken up with dates and opponents, we also have to see what happens with Paul.. can't say Tony ranks above Paul though that would be absurd. 100

[Haglerwins]

Margarito can only be ranked above Williams if Paul loses to Cintron.

[Verstyle]

Margarito can only be ranked above Williams if Paul loses to Cintron.

No,not even then.

[Haglerwins]

Yes he can. If Paul lost consider:

- Margarito only lost by 1 round to Williams.

- Marg soundly beat Cintron

[Verstyle]

Yes he can. If Paul lost consider:

- Margarito only lost by 1 round to Williams.

- Marg soundly beat Cintron

Does Margarito have like 5 loses?

[AntonTheMeh]

hell yeah.margarito beat the great "golden johnson"







































ah,the euphemisms are endless

[Haglerwins]

Does Margarito have like 5 loses?

I don't think it matters in this case, because if you account for recent happenings (and no I don't include the Golden Penis fight) at WW the top 5 look like this imo.

Floyd
Williams
Cotto
Marg
Cintron

or..

Floyd
Cotto
Williams
Marg
Cintron

I like the first set given Paul's win over Marg versus Cotto's win over Mosely. I wouldn't argue with the second list though, Shane's a big name even if I think he couldn't hang with the other WWs on the list. If you look at how close the 3 in question are in rank, a Cintron win versus Paul disrupts Williams remaining at the top of the 3 imo.. and you could arguably place Margarito above Williams because of the close loss and a solid W over Cintron.

Oh, and this would depend heavily on how Williams lost if he did lose to Kermit for a Marg above Williams ranking.

[BmoreBrawler]

Does Margarito have like 5 loses?

most of them are in tijuana, Mexico. He deserves honorary wins just for fighting there imo.