Is it Fair to rank Margarito over P. Williams???

[King Koopa]

Like when putting together your list of top Welterweights Right Now, is it fair to place Margarito over Williams although Williams won the close decision about 4 months ago

...not because of a victory over Golden Johnson

But because it was a close fight, where press row were split 4-4-4 (4 for Williams, 4 for Margarito and 4 a draw), that rendered a close UD Decision (115-113 across I think)

Is it fair then to say Margarito "can" still be ranked over Williams??
Would Williams be a heavy favorite in a rematch where Margarito came on strong at the end of their first bout?

btw, I had PW winning 115-113, boy was I happy he beat Margarito

[RAESAAD]

Margarito came on late but Williams clearly won the fight and dominated when he wanted to.....He is also undefeated....there is no way you can rank Margarito ahead of him at this point IMO.

[Spirit]

Williams clearly won the fight and should still be ranked above Margarito, I think it should stay that way until tony proves us wrong

[sterling]

yeh undefeated fighters are normally above defeated fighters in the p4p list if they have beat gd names in boxing and above 25+ fights and of course has a belt.

[THe TRiNiTY]

It was a close fight. However, he lost and fairly. Therefore, the only person a fight between Johnson and Margarito reflects upon is Johnson. It means, technically, he's below TWO guys for sure. In terms of accomplishments. Marge gets back on the winning streak, but that's it. He's not above Paul, not rightfully, because he's be proven to be BELOW him, in terms of fights. Plain and simple.

[Ray*]

I wouldnt put margarito over Williams just like how i wouldnt put Cintron over Margarito, All 3 fighters havent achieve anything yet IMO and we might be able to tell where they stand in 2 to 3years time.

[King Koopa]

So is it safe to say you guys would favor Williams in a rematch?
(if it ever happens)

[TheGR8TESTOAT]

yes! margarito is the most feared man in the sport! CUCUY!

[SkillspayBills]

I would rank Williams above him because Williams won fair and square.

[MaFu MoFo]

This issue will go up in flames if Kermit Cintron beats Paul Williams, then what??? At least, Cintron has spoken several times about fighting Margarito again. To be honest with you I would love to see the winner of Cintron-Williams to fight Margarito. Let Cotto KO DLH or MayWeather.