Even Larry Merchant said he had the cotto vs shane mosley a draw...

[FSUNoles46]

I stick by my original scoring of 115-113 for Cotto but it was a good fight and i wouldnt mind seeing them fight again.

[-Hyperion-]

almost anyone i respect in this forums had it a draw like myself.....im a fan of both BTW...

[pound4poundabes]

well, in my eyes this isnt even a loss for mosley , simply because mosley won the fight ...it was the crowd who won the fight for cotto ..everytime cotto would land anything at all .... the crowd would go CRAZY ... if this fight would have been in las vegas shane would have won ... but it was in puertorican territory ...they had a hispanic judge (who had shane behind the most in the fight) then they had another judge who had judge 2 of cotto's fight before ... this **** was all in cotto's favor ...




they need a rematch...but like i said it doesnt make no one look bad except for cotto because cotto ran and became the hunted ...

[Welter_Skelter]

HaHa.. OK. Sure, Welter.


Larry Merchant is in "the press" FYI..


That's proof right there, my friend. Objectivity? I don't think so.

I scored this fight a draw with OBJECTIVITY.

Are you questioning my integrity ADDY??????

if you are.. that hurts....

Merchant is senile... and has been for a few years now...

All I am asking is.. Where is the OFFICAL protest???

It took the WBC less than 48 hours to Declare a rematch between Casmayor and Cruiz...

If there was such an Injustice.. As we have seen many many times.. It gets sorted quickly...

Mosely is a nice guy???? Bull****.. he is a Boxer.. and like every boxer.. he wants to win.. If he truly felt he won.. We would be hearing about it..(Winky Wright anyone??)

Again I say.. people are unhappy about calling it wrong...

Pride is a very powerful thing..

[SkillspayBills]

Cotto won the fight in my opinion. I wouldn't be mad with someone saying Mosley won or a draw because it was a damn close fight. Where's Waldo?

[revs1227]

well, in my eyes this isnt even a loss for mosley , simply because mosley won the fight ...it was the crowd who won the fight for cotto ..everytime cotto would land anything at all .... the crowd would go CRAZY ... if this fight would have been in las vegas shane would have won ... but it was in puertorican territory ...they had a hispanic judge (who had shane behind the most in the fight) then they had another judge who had judge 2 of cotto's fight before ... this **** was all in cotto's favor ...




they need a rematch...but like i said it doesnt make no one look bad except for cotto because cotto ran and became the hunted ...

i agree but u fg the puerto rican ref who broke it up based on the fact that cotto was hurt and even gave him a min 2 recoop lol ..but n e way its in the past

[FSUNoles46]

What i dont get is that its been a week but we have people on here posting that Mosley definitely won. I'm not sure that you're going to convince anybody and, other than that, im not sure i understand the point of this.

[rambov]

I just hope there's a rematch

[Addison]

Are you questioning my integrity ADDY??????

if you are.. that hurts....

Merchant is senile... and has been for a few years now...

All I am asking is.. Where is the OFFICAL protest???

It took the WBC less than 48 hours to Declare a rematch between Casmayor and Cruiz...

If there was such an Injustice.. As we have seen many many times.. It gets sorted quickly...

Mosely is a nice guy???? Bull****.. he is a Boxer.. and like every boxer.. he wants to win.. If he truly felt he won.. We would be hearing about it..(Winky Wright anyone??)

Again I say.. people are unhappy about calling wrong...

Pride is a very powerful thing..

I think when people are saying over and over again that Mosley is a "class act" for not dis*****g the decision - that implies there was justification for Shane to dispute the decision and he opted not to do so.

I'm not questioning your integrity. You are questioning the integrity of anyone who says the fight was a draw or in favor of Mosley by stating that the only people who would do so are "Mosley fans" or "Cotto haters."

You are also stating that people are unhappy about picking wrong. So you have designated who and why someone would disagree with your finding.. I just think that's a tad unfair.

I totally respect and appreciate your integrity. You have a strong point of view on all things, and I wouldn't expect this to be any exception. I often agree with you, but in this case I just see it a slightly different way.

[PapiShasho]

It was a close fight, compared to all the recent Cotto massacres, but seriously, whoever thinks this fight was a draw does not know how to score fights.

COULD it have gone either way? Sure, it was that close, but the right decision was made, there's no controversy.