Whose the NEW #1 p4p fighter??

[old68]

Even if Kessler was a bonafide elite, which he isnt, although he is good... thats just one dude. Why would he be top P4P.

[sparked_85]

Because he is a dominant champion number one in his division for 10 years, undefeated, exciting. It's all subjective, if you don't rate Calzaghe you don't have to have him in your p4p at all. Your call in't it? I think from my understanding of P4p he'd be top because P4P he'd beat all the others and you wouldnt be able to have Floyd top if he lost. Who would you have anyway?

[SkillspayBills]

Pacman, duhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

[me2007]

Pacman, duhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

thanks for taking time out from your busy schedule to add that comment. You are a credit to the boxing community.

[sparked_85]

haha, fair enough though, I don't really take anyones p4p list anyway. Seriously though Audley Harrison p4p?

[gixxer]

Ok , suppose Floyd loses his #1 p4p status, due to losses to Hatton, and other possible fights in the pipeline, who do you think will replace him as the new no1. p4p fighter in the world?

I'd go with Miguel Angel Cotto.

Your thoughts..?

IT HAS TO BE FLOYD CUZ HES THE FASTES RUNNER EVER NO ONE CAN CATCH HIM PLUS HE HAS A HIGH KO PERCENTAGE ...............WOW WHAT A GUY NO WONDER MARGARITO WANTED NO PART IN HIM!!!!!!!!!LOL

[*AKO PA HA!]

If its Ring Magazine P4P ranking, its going to be Oscar.

post of the year!

[slicksouthpaw16]

]Because he is a dominant champion number one in his division for 10 years, undefeated, exciting. It's all[/B] subjective, if you don't rate Calzaghe you don't have to have him in your p4p at all. Your call in't it? I think from my understanding of P4p he'd be top because P4P he'd beat all the others and you wouldnt be able to have Floyd top if he lost. Who would you have anyway?

thank you. key points. thats exactly right. at least someone understands what i mean. Calzaghe should be number 1 if Floyd was knocked off the number 1 slot. Calzaghe has been dominate for 10 years and has been beating these young guns in thier primes. not to mention the 21 successful title defenses and undefeated record. i doubted Calzaghe before the Kessler fight but he proved to me that he is great fighter with that performance.

[old68]

Because he is a dominant champion number one in his division for 10 years, undefeated, exciting. It's all subjective, if you don't rate Calzaghe you don't have to have him in your p4p at all. Your call in't it? I think from my understanding of P4p he'd be top because P4P he'd beat all the others and you wouldnt be able to have Floyd top if he lost. Who would you have anyway?

I told you his division is mickey-mouse. P4P lists don't have much to do about being exciting, look who's topping the list right now. I'm sure he's a great but if Hatton wins both he and pacman will be topping most everyones list.

[EeZz]

P4P RANKING ACCORDING TO GIXXER AS OF NOVEMBER 16, 2007

1.ANTONIO MARGARITO
2.NOT IMPORTANT
3.WHO?
4.WHAT?
5.WHERE?
6.STOP
7.LOOK
8.AND
9.LISTEN

By knocking GOLDEN JOHNSON he should be p4p king. if any of you disagree. you guys dumb.