Roy Jones Jr at 168 would have beaten Calzaghe

[Wiley Hyena]

You are using hindsight. We are talking about Joe vs Roy at 168 not the 35 year old Roy who lost 20 pounds of pure muscle. Please enlighten me on how Cal would beat a Prime Roy Jones.

I'll enlighten you: Joe could beat Roy by frustrating him and outpointing him until Roy made a mistake and gets caught with a left hook that drops him.

That's how Joe could do it. Would I bet money on it? No. But, Calzaghe has disproved them all for 17 friggin years. No way am I going to now say Calzaghe has no chance against prime Roy. That's ******. Calzaghe has a chance against any SMW.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

RJJ beat 2 good fighters & people think he is the best P4P fighter ever ,lmfao

Think about the hypocrisy in what you just said.

How many good fighters did Cal beat? Who's resume would you rather have?

Hopkins+Toney+ Tarver... or
Eubank+Manfredo+ Kessler

[Parody]

I'll enlighten you: Joe could beat Roy by frustrating him and outpointing him until Roy made a mistake and gets caught with a left hook that drops him.

That's how Joe could do it. Would I bet money on it? No. But, Calzaghe has disproved them all for 17 friggin years. No way am I going to now say Calzaghe has no chance against prime Roy. That's ******. Calzaghe has a chance against any SMW.

Ofcourse he has a chance, but that was'nt my question...I respect your opinion sir. But frustrating and outpointing Roy Jones Jr?

[Azteca]

Zag showed more stones last night then Roy has in his entire career.

[Dynamite Kid]

Are you Serious, Calzaghe would kill roy, do you think Prime Roy Jones could handle Kabery Salem and Evans Ashira? U must be crazy.

Calzaghe is the greatest of all time, every single fighter from 168 upwards spent thier lives trying to aviod this guy, he had no choice but to fight Byron Mitchell etc etc.

What has roy jones done at 168? only beat a Prime undefeated James Toney, you think Toney is in the same Leauge as Kessler and Lacy?

Kessler beat libero andrade you know?

I think that makes him better than jones,

And Jones took steriods, everyone know steriods make you a more talented fighter, seriously, anyone can take them and become roy jones overnight.

Didnt you know this.

there called performance enhancing for a reason & if they were so inefectual he would'nt have taken it especially when you consider the pentaly it carries

Mosley ,Holyfeild,RJJ,Toney name a British fighter that fights under the influence of Steroids

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

I'll enlighten you: Joe could beat Roy by frustrating him and outpointing him until Roy made a mistake and gets caught with a left hook that drops him.

That's how Joe could do it. Would I bet money on it? No. But, Calzaghe has disproved them all for 17 friggin years. No way am I going to now say Calzaghe has no chance against prime Roy. That's ******. Calzaghe has a chance against any SMW.

And what would Roy be doing with his hands while Calzaghe is in range? Please enlighten us.

[Parody]

James Toney
Bernard Hopkins
Mike McCallum
Virgil Hill

Thats four HOF Fighters.

Others:

Tarver
Ruiz
Woods
Gonzales
Harding

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

there called performance enhancing for a reason & if they were so inefectual he would'nt have taken it especially when you consider the pentaly it carries

Mosley ,Holyfeild,RJJ,Toney name a British fighter that fights under the influence of Steroids

Do they even test?

[Dynamite Kid]

Think about the hypocrisy in what you just said.

How many good fighters did Cal beat? Who's resume would you rather have?

Hopkins+Toney+ Tarver... or
Eubank+Manfredo+ Kessler

1st off Joe is not a drugs cheat 2nd im not saying he is the best P4P fighter ever like some of the posters on this site ,nuff said see ya

[SkillspayBills]

I'll enlighten you: Joe could beat Roy by frustrating him and outpointing him until Roy made a mistake and gets caught with a left hook that drops him.

That's how Joe could do it. Would I bet money on it? No. But, Calzaghe has disproved them all for 17 friggin years. No way am I going to now say Calzaghe has no chance against prime Roy. That's ******. Calzaghe has a chance against any SMW.

Did I say he has no chance? NO. I said it is something I don't see happening. 17 years against who? Anyone NEAR the level of a prime RJJ, HELL NO. RJJ in his prime didn't get frustrated because he controled every aspect of the game during his bouts. Cal has a chance, a slim one at that. Cal is the greatest SMW of all time, but RJJ in his prime was one of the best ever, period.