JOE CALZAGHE is DEFINETLY above PACQUIAO in the p4p lists!

[QuCongee]

Pac and Floyd have wins in more weight classes. They define p4p because they have proven their skills while moving up in weight. As good as this win was, and it was a GREAT win, it's not big enough to trump beating Barrera and Morales x2. Pac has plenty of other solid wins too just like Calzaghe. Floyd's wins over Castillo and Corrales combined are better than Joe's wins over Lacy and Kessler.

Ok fair enough. Except for 1 point. And I can never stress it enough. Floyd got beat by Castillo in the first fight. **** what the record says. Everyone knows the truth.

[-Antonio-]

By today's standards sure. How many classes would Duran have dominated with the new divisions being figured in? That's a bull**** stat.
Besides, as I said, Floyd lost to Castillo. Period.

Then he clearly beat him in the rematch so your point isn't valid. And if you take away the extra divisions then there is no Super Middleweight division.

[SkillspayBills]

I can't believe you mentioned Manfredo. Manfredo doesn't deserve to be a ring card girl in one of Cal's matches let alone fight him. That being said you can very well make a case for Cal being number 2. Pac DID dominate Barerra (even though it was a tad lackluster) in the rematch once again.

[-Antonio-]

Ok fair enough. Except for 1 point. And I can never stress it enough. Floyd got beat by Castillo in the first fight. **** what the record says. Everyone knows the truth.

The rematch man. If Floyd didn't win the rematch you'd have a good point.

[SkillspayBills]

First learn how so spell DEFINITELY before typing it in caps.

Tht is one of the hardest words to spell though, seriously it is for some odd reason.

[SkillspayBills]

If Calzaghe fights Pavlik ever. And is able to beat Pavlik. I will go as far as saying Calzaghe is the greatest fighter ever. I don't care what anyone else says if they don't agree. Pavlik already proved himself by beating warriors like Zertuche, Miranda, taylor, McKart, and Fulgencio Zuniga.

lol it never fails, it happens after every fight.

[loui_ludwig]

I have JC anywhere from 3 to 5.

[rellik13]

Pac and Floyd have wins in more weight classes. They define p4p because they have proven their skills while moving up in weight. As good as this win was, and it was a GREAT win, it's not big enough to trump beating Barrera and Morales x2. Pac has plenty of other solid wins too just like Calzaghe. Floyd's wins over Castillo and Corrales combined are better than Joe's wins over Lacy and Kessler.

I agree. I would put him in top 5 though. Very impressive win.

[joepal]

IMO opinion at least. Not just beating, but DOMINATING everyone in his weightclass, including the best of the best. First Lacy, then Bika and Manfredo both good fighters, and now Kessler is a hell of a show.

1.Mayweather
2.Calzaghe
3.Pacquiao

thoughts?

Stop acting like Kessler was the p4p king when JoeCal beat him. Pac retains the number one spot. Joe can take Floyd's spot though.

[Run]

But yo, all that **** aside. You can't pick EX or Wink vs Zag, prime or w/e

"But Yo" You're completely misinformed.

I don't see how someone could pick Calzaghe over Hopkins prime 4 prime.

That's totally ******ed.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!