Who win against Zab was more impressive. Cotto's or Floyd's?

[AntonTheMeh]

Judah looked like he wasnt 100% from the start.

right........................

[ThaHorseman]

Im not taking anything away from Floyd's win. Not at all. He systematically broke judah down in the mid rounds, and like u said "cruised to a ud" But as far as Cotto taking "alot of punishment" How do u figure? Yeah he got caught with about 3 good solid uppercuts, but thats it. It was one and done moments that Judah had.

Do 3 solid shots bloody the **** out of you? Zab was pounding Cotto too, just not as bad as Cotto pounded him. Like I said before, its what you prefer. Oh yeah, I forgot that makes me a nuthugger.

[deevel79]

I mean this is a boxing board you should know at least a LITTLE bit about the sport before you come in here making ****** biased threads and whining about nuthuggers and Floyd Mayweather.
Grow up.

Answer my question. Dont resort to spin. You discredit Cotto's win against Zab because, and quoted "it came 1yr after Floyd beat him"

How is that so much different or worst than Floyd facing him 3months after Baldomir beat on him?

[deevel79]

Do 3 solid shots bloody the **** out of you? Zab was pounding Cotto too, just not as bad as Cotto pounded him. Like I said before, its what you prefer. Oh yeah, I forgot that makes me a nuthugger.

Im not sure if u really watched the fight, but the blood was a result of a HEADBUTT that cut Cotto's lip.

[ThaHorseman]

Im not sure if u really watched the fight, but the blood was a result of a HEADBUTT that cut Cotto's lip.

I'm not sure if you've ever had a cut lip, but the blood usually doesn't end up all over your face.

[SkillspayBills]

And Floyd fought Judah 3months after Baldomir put Judah on ***** street and beat him. So your point is?

Yes, Floyd took over down the stretch and was winning the rounds. I wouldnt call it "beating the **** outta him" though. What Cotto did was "beat the **** outta him"

Cotto beat Judah a year and 3 months after he was put on ***** street by Baldomir and systematically whooped on by Mayweather. Dios does have a bit of a point, Judah was damaged goods. I won't take anything from Cotto though he came to fight and he tore Judah up something new.

[-Antonio-]

Zab didnt look any different than he did against Floyd. He showed up in excellent shape, said before the fight that he was in the best shape of his life. He didnt look any slower, didnt lose his reflexes. The layoff isnt a big issue.

And this isnt an easy choise by any means. Floyd pressured Zab just as effectively. I just think Cotto's punches left more of an impact in the long run. Had Judah hurt several times, knocked him down twice, and eventually stopped him. Closed his eye too, although I believe Floyd had Judah's lip busted.

[deevel79]

I'm not sure if you've ever had a cut lip, but the blood usually doesn't end up all over your face.

When there's a HOLE IN YOUR LIP it does. Cmon Horseman. Your in a boxing match. You have a hole in your lip. Do u really think the blood is going to stay in one little specific area? It was more than just a cut lip. I suggest u rewatch the fight.

[-Antonio-]

Damaged goods, that's ridiculous. You cant give Floyd credit for beating Judah and not Cotto. That's bull****. A year layoff does not mean your downfall. Fighters have done this before.

[Slotff]

Cotto's win was more impressive. He ground down, dominated and stopped Judah, while Floyd adjusted from a shaky start and still was made to look extremely uncomfortable when Zab started to cheat.

They both came from shaky starts wouldn't you say?. But it is clearly Cotto who gets the nod.

Baldomir had a more impressive win. Beating an Undisputed Champion in a prime Judah. Plus he just about took his head off.