James Toney vs Kelly Pavlik

[Parody]

How would this match up go? If someone votes for Pavlik I will throw up...

Also how would these match-ups go:

In their primes:

Roy Jones vs Kelly Pavlik
vs Joe Calzaghe

James Toney vs Joe Calzaghe (Prime for Prime)

[ßringer]

Pavlik easily beats Toney, Jones and Calzaghe all in the same night, 3 on 1.

[Parody]

Pavlik easily beats Toney, Jones and Calzaghe all in the same night, 3 on 1.

..........

[oldgringo]

Pavlik easily beats Toney, Jones and Calzaghe all in the same night, 3 on 1.

i concur. after the fight he sleeps with their respective wives while chain smoking turkish cigarettes.

[ßringer]

Seriously though, Kelly's got a lot of ****wagon jumpers since the Taylor fight. People claiming to support him but they really just disliked Taylor. So that's where the nonsense about how unbeatable Pavlik is comes from.

I'm a diehard Pavlik fan since '05 but I can admit he's not the best. His handspeed is lacking and his defense is still kind shaky, he's my boy but he can be beat.

Onto the question seriously.

A prime Middleweight Toney would take Pavlik easily. Jones I'm not so sure of because his style in his prime was mostly based on athletic moves and feats of courage. If he got ballsy and stuck his chin out to Kelly I'm not sure he'd avoid it. I'd go with Jones by some boring UD.

Vs Calzaghe, Pavlik crushes him, any day, anytime, anywhere. Joe's punches don't pack the punch to hurt Kelly and if you couple that with his shaky defense I think Pavlik would ultimately pressure him into submission.

[ßringer]

i concur. after the fight he sleeps with their respective wives while chain smoking turkish cigarettes.

Then their wives all comment about how much larger Kelly's penis is than their husbands. And to top it all off, Pavlik wins "Dancing with the Stars" without even entering the competition.

[Thread Stealer]

Pavlik does beat the Toney @ 160 who showed up for the Tiberi fight.

[oldgringo]

Pavlik does beat the Toney @ 160 who showed up for the Tiberi fight.

well yeah, just like he beats roy jones who showed up for ricky randall.....

[Maxy]

Toney at his best beats Pavlik every day of the week. No problem.

Calzaghe has been around too long to suggest Pavlik beats him easily.

[Thread Stealer]

well yeah, just like he beats roy jones who showed up for ricky randall.....

but that was a young roy making his debut.

the toney who got a gift over tiberi was a world champ who had faced fighters such as nunn, mccallum, sosa, and r. johnson.

as it is, i don't see pavlik beating toney in his other title fights @ 160.

maybe the mccallum rematch. i was not impressed with toney's performance that night.

i thought toney looked a lot better in the draw in the first fight.