better achievements: carlos baldomir or antonio margarito?

[-Hyperion-]

Baldomir...not even up for debate.....margarito could only dream of becoming undisputed welterweight champ....

[joepal]

honestly? when he fought Diego Corrales.. however when he disposed of him the way he did I stopped doubting him since.. I haven't seen someone dispose of someone who was so highly favored to win since Buster Douglass beat Mike Tyson, not even Joe Calzaghe-Jeff Lacy compares cuz Joe couldn't finish Jeff, he got hit more than Mayweather and expended more of himself in the fight than what Floyd did.. Floyd not only won but he made it look effortless, I remember being blown away by his performance, I was watching that fight with my father and we couldn't believe it.. all due respect though to Chico (R.I.P).. 100

Even with this standard you fail. Floyd was already a p4p fighter then, it's not as if he wasn't rated. Hell Pac wasnt even rated in the top 60 when he fought the p4p no. 3 MAB.

[ßringer]

Baldomir...not even up for debate.....margarito could only dream of becoming undisputed welterweight champ....

Right there bitches, and that's coming from a real Mexican.

[joepal]

Great. Some jerks just voted for a guy with 12 losses. Time to report these non-serious posters to the boss.

[deevel79]

And Clottey was whoopin Marg's ass until he hurt his hand. So what are you getting at? ONly one was linear WW champion of the world although they BOTH fought in the WW division.

If Margo would've faced the same Judah that Baldo faced, he would've won aswell. I have Margo beating both Judah and Gatti. Margo has a cast iron chin and would've took Judah down the stretch. Gatti? He got crushed by Baldo and that contender guy Gomez. You dont think Margo would've done the same to Gatti, maybe worst?

Just for the record, im not even a Margarito fan.

[Easy-E]

Theres no competition.
Won the linear welterweight champion of the world agasint the extremely talented champion, beat the betting odds and succesfully defended his title, and then went 12 with Floyd, and showed heart and effort and competitive spirit throughout the fight.

Margo won a vacant title.

[Easy-E]

Great. Some jerks just voted for a guy with 12 losses. Time to report these non-serious posters to the boss.

Sugar Ray had 19 losses.

Who had the better achivements, Margo or SSR?

[ztrac79]

I vote Baldy even though I'd have to pick Tony to win if they were to ever fight.

[RAESAAD]

Well seeing how Baldy was considered the undisputed WW Champ at one point and has fought both Mayweather and Judah which are two better fighters than anyone on Margys resume except maybe Williams than I have to go with Baldy.

[Pugilistic™]

baldomir easy ....