Will Floyd go down as an ATG If he beats Hatton?

[AntonTheMeh]

There are plenty of fighters better then those 3 that Floyd has beaten. On a p4p scale of course. Vargas and Sturm are jr.middle/middleweights. Floyd has only beaten one Jr.middleweight in his first try at 154.

Castillo, Corrales alone are better victories then Vargas and Sturm. Quartey was a very good welterweight back in his day. If floyd beats Hatton, that will equall to the Quartey victory Oscar has.

P4P TITO PUTS THE BEATS ON EVERYBODY FLOYD BEAT PERIOD.CASTILLO CORRALES WHATEVER.SO DOES VARGAS.SO DOES QUARTEY AND PERNELL AND EVEN AN OLD ASS CAMACHO,CHAVEZ ETC....

[Dirt E Gomez]

DOMI TO SABES LA PREGUNTA.WHERE DOES HE RANK AMONG THE ALL TIME GREATS.HIS RESUME HANDICAPS HIM,TO BEING IN THERE WITH TITO AND OSCAR.IS HE BETTER THAN BOTH YES.HIS RESUME ISN'T BETTER THAN THEIRS THOUGH.

It depends on you want to qualify the ATG's then. If it's strictly by their W's, their lack of L's, how decisive their wins are, who they all fought as a whole, how much they dominated or didn't, if they struggled w/ mediocre opposition? There's a lot to think when talking about all time greats.

[Vladimir303]

From what i've seen Mayweather gets hometown decisions also,

Castillo/Mayweather was a close fight that could have went either way. Fortunately it went Floyd's way.

Oscar/Floyd. One judge scored it for Oscar which is ridiculous. Everybody saw that Floyd took over in the 2nd half of the fight and secured the victory.

You got it all wrong.

[Dirt E Gomez]

well if ALL dlh DID WAS LOSE TO HOPKINS, THEN YES BEATING jUDAH WOULD BE BETTER, BUT IS THAT all DLH did Dirty?


Think about it stool pigeon!

He didn't just lose to Hopkins. He lost, and should have lost, plenty of times. But is beating Judah the only think PBF did? Street runs both ways.

You're silly, Eaton.

[Easton Assassin]

He didn't just lose to Hopkins. He lost, and should have lost, plenty of times. But is beating Judah the only think PBF did? Street runs both ways.

You're silly, Eaton.

No Mayweather beat Judah, bruselles,Gatti, Ndou, Mitchell, Manfredy and every other past it or c-level guy .

In the process he managed to avoid every true division champ along the way to Omnipotence and nuthuggery by dirty little gomezes like yourself!

[Vladimir303]

P4P TITO PUTS THE BEATS ON EVERYBODY FLOYD BEAT PERIOD.CASTILLO CORRALES WHATEVER.SO DOES VARGAS.SO DOES QUARTEY AND PERNELL AND EVEN AN OLD ASS CAMACHO,CHAVEZ ETC....

And floyd beats tito. Floyd's quote "Oscar called me a runner, If Oscar knew how to run like me he would have beaten Trinidad".

Which is true.....Floyd would have stayed consistant and finished off the job instead of pointlessly running away from confrontation and losing rounds for no reason.

[AntonTheMeh]

It depends on you want to qualify the ATG's then. If it's strictly by their W's, their lack of L's, how decisive their wins are, who they all fought as a whole, how much they dominated or didn't, if they struggled w/ mediocre opposition? There's a lot to think when talking about all time greats.

DIRT E
YOU'RE MAKING THIS HARDER THAN IT SHOULD.HE IS ON PAR WITH OSCAR ALL TIME,HANDICAP BY HIS LEGACY.IS HE BETTER YES.HIS RESUME ISN'T.SUGAR RAY ROBINSON ISN'T CONSIDERED THE GREATEST BECAUSE HE BEAT A BUNCH OF BUMS.HE BEAT A TON OF HALL OF FAMERS.YOU THINK ALI WOULD BE CONSIDERED THE GREATEST HEAVYWEIGHT IF HE DIDN'T BEAT WHO HE BEAT?

[Dirt E Gomez]

P4P TITO PUTS THE BEATS ON EVERYBODY FLOYD BEAT PERIOD.CASTILLO CORRALES WHATEVER.SO DOES VARGAS.SO DOES QUARTEY AND PERNELL AND EVEN AN OLD ASS CAMACHO,CHAVEZ ETC....

Tito is one of the most overrated fighter of the last 20 ****ing years. Then you're going to start talking about a very old Chavez, Camacho... mother ****ing Vargas? The juicer who doesn't have a single good W on his resume outside of a lesser Winky who he barely beat and Quartey?

Now you're being delusional.

[AntonTheMeh]

And floyd beats tito. Floyd's quote "Oscar called me a runner, If Oscar knew how to run like me he would have beaten Trinidad".

Which is true.....Floyd would have stayed consistant and finished off the job instead of pointlessly running away from confrontation and losing rounds for no reason.

IT'S NOT ABOUT MATCHUPS IT'S ABOUT WHO YOU BEAT YOU.IN THIS CASE FLOYD.COULD FLOYD BEAT DURAN? YOU WOULD ANSWER YES WOULDN'T YOU.

[AntonTheMeh]

Tito is one of the most overrated fighter of the last 20 ****ing years. Then you're going to start talking about a very old Chavez, Camacho... mother ****ing Vargas? The juicer who doesn't have a single good W on his resume outside of a lesser Winky who he barely beat and Quartey?

Now you're being delusional.

THIS ISN'T ABOUT TITO.YOU KNOW WHAT FORGET IT.