Will Floyd go down as an ATG If he beats Hatton?

[newforce]

Will Floyd go down as an ATG If he beats Hatton this december and retires undefeated.?

[BrooklynBomber]

....An underdog that majority is expecting Floyd to beat rather easily anyway?....


I don't think so.

[jlf85]

if he beat both cotto and mosley i would give him respect.

[demirturk]

many will say no right now , but yes he will be remembered as one of the best years later, thats the way it goes...

[AntonTheMeh]

he'll be in oscar territory.

[demirturk]

he'll be in oscar territory.

are you serious?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

he'll be in oscar territory.

Um, no.

There's no legacy upside for Floyd. With the exception of saying that he beat the best at 140.

In my eyes, Floyd can only go down in this fight. Beating a mediocre fighter like Hatton means little. Losing to a guy of Hatton's calibre would knock him down a peg unless he avenges it.

[me2007]

he's in a no win situation.

all his fans think hatton is a bum.

if he wins, he beat a bum (who cares)

if he loses, he lost to a bum and his whole career is a joke

[Dirt E Gomez]

Depends on what Hatton does w/ his career. At the moment Hatton is a star, but his entire resume rests on the shoulders of a win over an old Tszyu. If he loses to Floyd but goes on to have a successful career while beating good champions along the way it'll mean a lot more.

True ATG status and the like is hard to determine w/ active fighters. Years after they retire the big picture can be looked at.

[AntonTheMeh]

Um, no.

There's no legacy upside for Floyd. With the exception of saying that he beat the best at 140.

In my eyes, Floyd can only go down in this fight. Beating a mediocre fighter like Hatton means little. Losing to a guy of Hatton's calibre would knock him down a peg unless he avenges it.

so seriously.tell me where you rank him.