Poll: Floyd v. Castillo I...who won?

[Barlog]

castillo won the first fight, and was robbed. floid won the rematch, he adjusted to castillo's style and won the 2nd fight

Adjustments my a**.Why don`t you idiots(for those that apply) go rewatch the fight and listen to when Mayweather was complaining about his shoulder in the corners in the early rounds.


He hurt his shoulder in sparring in preperation for the fight.

[THe TRiNiTY]

What's this, I merely ask you to susbtantiate your Kessler offense theory and you're already throwing the towel? Was your "I think Juan Diaz, Ricky Hatton, Mikkel Kessler might have better offenses than Manny, p4p, by the way" just a fleeting flight of fancy? Now you are changing your mind? Fickle-mindedness is a female characteristic. Hey ***got, YOU JUST DONT MAKE BOLD CLAIMS HERE AND FAIL TO EXPLAIN IT. C'mon man. How is throwing a feather-fisted jab at Andrade better than throwing a straight left to Morales' face that immediately sent him down, crumbling in a heap? You're the one making all these outlandish observations so it is incumbent upon you to explain it thoroughly.

Uhuh, OKay. You got me. You win. Goodnight.

[joepal]

Uhuh, OKay. You got me. You win. Goodnight.

Next time don't make claims you can't back-up. And stop claiming your objective for chrissake!

[MayweatherDaMan]

Joepal you're a ***, pure and simple.

Funny how you have "pal" in your name, because by the looks of it, the amount of time you spend on these forums, coupled with 1358 posts in the space of 2 MONTHS, suggests you don't have a life outside these forums, hence, no "pals".

I was laughing as I was reading your arguments with C-Drone, because he is making genuine points, and then your only comeback is to fault a very minor spelling error of his, or completely twist what he has said, just because you don't have any half decent responses to come back with.

That aside, I agree with the people who say the first fight was very close, and could have gone either way. The fact of the matter is that the victory went to Floyd, and another useless topic on these forums claiming that Castillo was robbed isn't going to change a damn thing.

Floyd is 38-0 my friends. He didn't "offically lose" or he would be 37-1 wouldn't he.

He then also proved his doubters wrong by giving Castillo the rematch, and winning that a lot more comfortably then the first match.

Life goes on, Mayweather haters, get over it!

[-EX-]

Mayweather won the CLOSE fight. There was no robbery.

[Wiley Hyena]

Joepal you're a ***, pure and simple.

Funny how you have "pal" in your name, because by the looks of it, the amount of time you spend on these forums, coupled with 1358 posts in the space of 2 MONTHS, suggests you don't have a life outside these forums, hence, no "pals".

I was laughing as I was reading your arguments with C-Drone, because he is making genuine points, and then your only comeback is to fault a very minor spelling error of his, or completely twist what he has said, just because you don't have any half decent responses to come back with.

That aside, I agree with the people who say the first fight was very close, and could have gone either way. The fact of the matter is that the victory went to Floyd, and another useless topic on these forums claiming that Castillo was robbed isn't going to change a damn thing.

Floyd is 38-0 my friends. He didn't "offically lose" or he would be 37-1 wouldn't he.

He then also proved his doubters wrong by giving Castillo the rematch, and winning that a lot more comfortably then the first match.

Life goes on, Mayweather haters, get over it!

The poll overwhelmingly disagrees with you. Therefore, for analytical purposes, you have to count Floyd's first fight with Castillo as a loss.

[Vladimir303]

.........................

[Vladimir303]

The poll overwhelmingly disagrees with you. Therefore, for analytical purposes, you have to count Floyd's first fight with Castillo as a loss.

You don't have to count anything. Haters will vote that he lost. Hell Joepal even said that he lost the second fight. Credibility and neutral discussion goes out the window with people like that.

[Maxy]

You don't have to count anything. Haters will vote that he lost. Hell Joepal even said that he lost the second fight. Credibility and neutral discussion goes out the window with people like that.

Most neutrals would say Castillo won the first fight.

[Vladimir303]

Most neutrals would say Castillo won the first fight.

Well they have the right to their opinion. As long as you keep in mind that no matter what.....that fight was close and competitive.

I scored round for round and I had floyd winning 114-112. That's 6 rounds to 5 with 1 even. The ref took away points from both guys.

Most who see this will of course tell me that it's bull**** and that Castillo CLEARLY won. And those people are not being neutral at all. Because nothing was clear about that fight but that it could have went either way.