Floyd defeated Castillo in 1st fight

[warp1432]

Punch stats are invalid either way.

The point is, Oscar's rallies were missing 85% of the punches thrown, maybe even higher. That and Floyd was direct with his shots that won him the fight.

People shouldn't go by punch stat numbers at all.

And for the record, even though I already said it earlier in the thread, I had it 115-113 for Floyd. Could of easily seen 116-112 too. Not so much on 117-111 or higher...

[Jim Jeffries]

I already said i thought Castillo won the 1st fight so what are you on about ??

Sorry man. I just watched a CLEAR video of it (not that garbled Utube ****) and I'm still pissed.

[Burning Desire]

Sorry man. I just watched a CLEAR video of it (not that garbled Utube ****) and I'm still pissed.

No problem im Mayweather fan but im not biased i think Castillo won by 2 rounds.

[Jim Jeffries]

Punch stats are invalid either way.

The point is, Oscar's rallies were missing 85% of the punches thrown, maybe even higher. That and Floyd was direct with his shots that won him the fight.

People shouldn't go by punch stat numbers at all.

So how do you score a fight besides who lands the cleaner harder shots?

[warp1432]

Effective agression, Defense, Clean Punching, and Ring Generalship.

The basic scoring criteras of the unified rules of the boxing association.

JIM!!!

[Jim Jeffries]

Effective agression, Defense, Clean Punching, and Ring Generalship.

The basic scoring criteras of the unified rules of the boxing association.

JIM!!!

Does ring generalship include elbows to the throat? Just curious.

[warp1432]

Does ring generalship include elbows to the throat? Just curious.

Does Ring Generalship include excessive holding?

Though it depends on the situation. I guess.

[Vladimir303]

I'm guessing you didn't watch the fight at all.

rd 1 - Floyd
rd 2 - Floyd
rd 3 - Castillo
rd 4 - Close
rd 5 - Castillo
rd 6 - Castillo
rd 7 - Castillo
rd 8 - Castillo he lost a point
rd 9 - Floyd (should have lost a point for hitting after the bell)
rd 10- Castillo Floyd loses a point, if you think this was Floyd's best round of the fight then you must REALLY think Floyd lost.
rd 11- Close
rd 12- Close

The two points that were deducted cancel each other out. Giving Castillo just ONE of the THREE rounds that were too close to call wins him the fight.
Giving him NONE of those three rounds gives him a draw, he retains his championship belt.

Floyd owes his "0" to three very ignorant(and probably now very rich) judges that night.

I watched the fight kid.........it was a close fight and I had Floyd winning. You think otherwise fine.

[Jim Jeffries]

I watched the fight kid.........it was a close fight and I had Floyd winning. You think otherwise fine.

I tried changing the first line. Anyway, you didn't have Casamayor winning his last fight by any chance?

[warp1432]

**** no. Casamayor lost that fight for sure.