Floyd defeated Castillo in 1st fight

[ThaHorseman]

I have a much better quality version on my computer. And I just watched it and am still fuming. Maybe some other time though. One of the most rediculous decisions I've ever seen (because of the lopsidedness of the judges scorecards.)

Even I would agree with you on that. But to say its a robbery is just as ridiculous. I thought there were 5 rounds that each fighter won clearly and 2 that were toss-ups. Either way, it was a damn close fight. Anyone saying it was a robbery or CLEAR decision for Castillo are just as crazy as anyone saying it was a clear victory for Floyd. It could've gone either way. There is no dis*****g that.

[Mozza]

I watched the fight again a few days ago and though I thought Castillo had won it was won of those fights that you can't complain about going either way.

[Burning Desire]

More like 36-2 when he lost to JLC and DLH.

If you think DLH won Mayweather fight you obvisiously can't score a fight properly or you have biased scoring one of the two.

[jawsmafia]

has anyone noticed in all of these posts(including the one i made begging people who scored the fight for JLC, to post their scorecards only the floyd fans have done so? maybe cos most of them havent seen the fight or jst hate floyd

I ended up scoring it
Mayweather: 10 10 10 10 9 9 9 10 9 8 9 9
Castillo: 9 9 9 9 10 10 10 8 10 10 10 10

I think Castillo won the fight 114-112 I'm indifferent to Floyd but he lost this fight and i think the reason maybe a lot of people call this a robbery including myself is because the margins by the judges were outrageous and ridiculous, lederman, lampley and merchant all said they thought castillo won, now I can see it close, and I can see it tied if Floyd won the 5th even though I scored it for Castillo, but in no way did Castillo lose this fight 116-111 115-111

[Jim Jeffries]

Even I would agree with you on that. But to say its a robbery is just as ridiculous. I thought there were 5 rounds that each fighter won clearly and 2 that were toss-ups. Either way, it was a damn close fight. Anyone saying it was a robbery or CLEAR decision for Castillo are just as crazy as anyone saying it was a clear victory for Floyd. It could've gone either way. There is no dis*****g that.

The thing is, the judges had it 8 rounds to 4 for Floyd. And Castillo was the champ in this fight who is supposed to get some benefit of the doubt. The way they had it scored, there was NO way for Castillo to win. Not counting the first two rounds, which Floyd won, Castillo dominated the fight, and please show me the 2 rounds that Floyd clearly won, besides 1,2 and 9.

[Chicago]

PBF won that fight, anyone else who fails to see that is blind.

[warp1432]

Though hypothetically speaking, since I had it 7-5 for Floyd maybe they just decided to give Floyd an extra round in one of the (many) close rounds.

For example, I had it 8-4 for Bernard in the Winky fight, but could have easily seen it 9-3 or 7-5. It's just what you perfer I guess. Though, 116-111 is a bit strange...

[Burning Desire]

PBF won that fight, anyone else who fails to see that is blind.

Don't be silly just because you have different opinion doesn't mean your right and everyone else is wrong and in this case you couldn't be more wrong it was close fight im Mayweather fan i think Castillo won the fight by atleast 2 rounds maybe 1 but like i said Mayweather won the rematch easily so it doesn't matter anymore.

[ThaHorseman]

The thing is, the judges had it 8 rounds to 4 for Floyd. And Castillo was the champ in this fight who is supposed to get some benefit of the doubt. The way they had it scored, there was NO way for Castillo to win. Not counting the first two rounds, which Floyd won, Castillo dominated the fight, and please show me the 2 rounds that Floyd clearly won, besides 1,2 and 9.

Does it matter if he won it by SD or 12 rounds to 0? Would it have made it easier for you to accept it if the scores were closer? The judges are supposed to base their scores on what THEY see. Whether you see it or not is irrevelant.

[Mike Tyson77]

Didnt Floyd beat this man twice?