Who has the better legacy, Pacquiao or Mayweather?

[sonofisis]

So you think Hatton is to his division what EM and MAB was to theirs?

MAB and Morales are only two fighters who were both out of their primes. Floyd cleaned out 130 and 135, after that beating a HOF in De La Hoya in addition to winning belts at 140 and 147.. Pac doesn't compare at all, which is why delusional Pac fans can only reference these same two fighters who Pac keeps picking on..

[rellik13]

MAB and Morales are only two fighters who were both out of their primes. Floyd cleaned out 130 and 135, after that beating a HOF in De La Hoya in addition to winning belts at 140 and 147.. Pac doesn't compare at all, which is why delusional Pac fans can only reference these same two fighters who Pac keeps picking on..

LOL is that all you got? DLH of 2007 is equivalent to a MAB of 2003 and a EM of 05? Is that all? Name Floyd's most exciting fight?

[sonofisis]

LOL is that all you got? DLH of 2007 is equivalent to a MAB of 2003 and a EM of 05? Is that all? Name Floyd's most exciting fight?

The fact the you admit that MAB and Morales were both basically downhill is a perfect opportunity for me to present Floyd's resume vs. Pac's at 130 alone.. From another thread...

Pac is 6-1 at 130 lbs and has fought the following people..


Marco Antonio Barrera 130 63-5


Jorge Solis 130 32-0-2


Erik Morales 129 48-4-0


Oscar Larios 129 56-4-1


Erik Morales 130 48-3-0


Hector Velazquez 130 42-10-2


Erik Morales 130 47-2

Mayweather was 26-0 at 130, with 9 title defenses and more meaningful fights, against the following..

Jesus Chavez 129½ 36-1-0


Carlos Hernandez 128½ 33-2-1


Diego Corrales 130 33-0-0


Emanuel Augustus 134 22-16-4


Gregorio Vargas 130 40-6-1


Carlos Gerena 130 34-2-0


Justin Juuko 130 33-2-1


Carlos Alberto Ramon Rios 129 44-2-1


Angel Manfredy 130 25-2-1


Genaro Hernandez 130 38-1-1


Tony Pep 130 39-6-0

Nuff said..

[joepal]

Pacquiao. Resume-wise, and I really think he beats the beejesus out of the Castillo that owned Floyd.

Excitment and contribution to the sport, NO FRIGGING COMPARISON.

Cojones-wise, NO FRIGGING COMPARISON. He'd fight Hatton AT 140 IN MANCHESTER.

Personality-wise, a million times better than the braggart.

Actually everything-wise, Manny Pacquiao > Floyd Mayweather. It's even blasphemy to compare the two at this point.

[joepal]

The fact the you admit that MAB and Morales were both basically downhill is a perfect opportunity for me to present Floyd's resume vs. Pac's at 130 alone.. From another thread...




Mayweather was 26-0 at 130, with 9 title defenses and more meaningful fights, against the following..

Jesus Chavez 129½ 36-1-0


Carlos Hernandez 128½ 33-2-1


Diego Corrales 130 33-0-0


Emanuel Augustus 134 22-16-4


Gregorio Vargas 130 40-6-1


Carlos Gerena 130 34-2-0


Justin Juuko 130 33-2-1


Carlos Alberto Ramon Rios 129 44-2-1


Angel Manfredy 130 25-2-1


Genaro Hernandez 130 38-1-1


Tony Pep 130 39-6-0

Nuff said..

It really is a shame whenever somebody compares the likes of Rios, Juuko and Manfredy, etc. to the likes of MAB (TWICE), Morales (THRICE), and JMM, etc. Guy really has no business analyzing boxing.

[Joartcc3]

After Manny's second win over Barrera who do you guys think has the better legacy? Who is the better fighter overall? Who would win in a mythical match up?

Fake Floyd has ducked all the top opposition and handpicks his opponents.

Even you Antonio could see that.

Pac is being chased by every elite in the 130-135 division and Pac is lining them all up and retiring them.

What more can you ask.

[Joartcc3]

The fact the you admit that MAB and Morales were both basically downhill is a perfect opportunity for me to present Floyd's resume vs. Pac's at 130 alone.. From another thread...




Mayweather was 26-0 at 130, with 9 title defenses and more meaningful fights, against the following..

Jesus Chavez 129½ 36-1-0


Carlos Hernandez 128½ 33-2-1


Diego Corrales 130 33-0-0


Emanuel Augustus 134 22-16-4


Gregorio Vargas 130 40-6-1


Carlos Gerena 130 34-2-0


Justin Juuko 130 33-2-1


Carlos Alberto Ramon Rios 129 44-2-1


Angel Manfredy 130 25-2-1


Genaro Hernandez 130 38-1-1


Tony Pep 130 39-6-0

Nuff said..

Dude. Those names aren't even comparable to MAB and Morales.

Dude you're funny.

[Dirt E Gomez]

My opinion is that the whole lot of 'em... Barrera, Pacquiao, JMM, and Morales are overrated as a whole. They put on great shows, show tremendous heart, and mean a lot to boxing; but I don't think they're all time greats. People are quick to point out there records... but when you look at it you see their best wins are all over eachother.

That being said, Pacquiao has the better legacy as of now. Not to say he's a better fighter, has a better p4p ranking, or even has a better resume. In many fan's eyes they'll be quick to remember some of his wars and the good fights he had and overlook the others.

However, when Mayweather takes out Hatton and puts a handful of more W's under his belt then the favor shifts back over to Floyd where it will stay.

[Joartcc3]

My opinion is that the whole lot of 'em... Barrera, Pacquiao, JMM, and Morales are overrated as a whole. They put on great shows, show tremendous heart, and mean a lot to boxing; but I don't think they're all time greats. People are quick to point out there records... but when you look at it you see their best wins are all over eachother.

That being said, Pacquiao has the better legacy as of now. Not to say he's a better fighter, has a better p4p ranking, or even has a better resume. In many fan's eyes they'll be quick to remember some of his wars and the good fights he had and overlook the others.

However, when Mayweather takes out Hatton and puts a handful of more W's under his belt then the favor shifts back over to Floyd where it will stay.

THIS IS THE ALL-TIME DUMBEST POST I HAVE EVER SEEN.

MAB, Morales and JMM overrated? Lols!

Actually Fake Floyd running like a chilcken from Baldomir and an old DLH is OVERRATED.

Dude where's your brain?

[Sudo]

If you look just for fights, they are even.
If you look entertainment wise, acting in public, recpect shown to opponents -> Manny >> Floyd.