Who wins now: PBF vs Punisher

[CottoOverrated1]

Damn Kayjay, you act like you lost money in the margarito-williams bout. To say Hatton is a tougher match up for anyone between 140-147 lbs is IMO ridiculous.

[CottoOverrated1]

skinny pun by ud

lol @ skinny pun. I'm glad its catching on.

[kayjay]

Damn Kayjay, you act like you lost money in the margarito-williams bout. To say Hatton is a tougher match up for anyone between 140-147 lbs is IMO ridiculous.

I just get annoyed by the fighter of the minute phenomenon, and the fact that people make an issue over the man's height. Height's not a problem for a great boxer, and Mayweather is a great boxer.

And I never thought much of Maragrito, so that fight did little for me.

[donatopulla]

Read again buddy. I said Hatton is a tougher fight for Floyd That doesn't mean Hatton could beat Williams.

Williams before long will have to move up in weight and get killed.

Do you think that oaf would have a prayer against Cotto?

Listen to this guy, you act like Williams stole your girlfriend, you're the definition of a hater, in the dictionary it should have a pic of your ugly ass. Hatton is tougher for Floyd?? How the hell does Hatton pose more of a problem then Williams?? Williams is way faster, way longer, throws way more punches, has way better angles, and is southpaw. Idiot.

Williams will move up in weight and dominate. A prayer against Cotto?? He'd mop the floor with Cotto

[donatopulla]

I just get annoyed by the fighter of the minute phenomenon, and the fact that people make an issue over the man's height. Height's not a problem for a great boxer, and Mayweather is a great boxer.

And I never thought much of Maragrito, so that fight did little for me.

But you think a lot of Hatton and Cotto, two guys Margarito would beat. Heigh isn't a problem for a great boxer?? Your knowledge continues to destroy this forum...just do everybody a favor and stop posting

[CottoOverrated1]

I just get annoyed by the fighter of the minute phenomenon, and the fact that people make an issue over the man's height. Height's not a problem for a great boxer, and Mayweather is a great boxer.

And I never thought much of Maragrito, so that fight did little for me.

I understand that but I been praising Williams since the ESPN days. I got a good 4-5 fights under my belt watching this guy. I hate the fighter of the minute too, but Williams is the real deal, he just needs more oppurtunities to showcase it.

You are right about height, but incorrect with the logic you used for this situation. Pun got the skills to pay the bills. he aint like miranda who is going to try to run you over. Pun uses movement and a volume of punches that will make anyone gasping for a air after 2 rounds if they werent as well conditioned as he is. when you got skill and height thats dangerous. thats what we see.

and you know the old Merchant saying " A good big man beats a good little man if they are evenly matched"

am i saying Paul is as skilled as PBF, hell no. nobody is. But he is a good big man.

[kayjay]

I understand that but I been praising Williams since the ESPN days. I got a good 4-5 fights under my belt watching this guy. I hate the fighter of the minute too, but Williams is the real deal, he just needs more oppurtunities to showcase it.

You are right about height, but incorrect with the logic you used for this situation. Pun got the skills to pay the bills. he aint like miranda who is going to try to run you over. Pun uses movement and a volume of punches that will make anyone gasping for a air after 2 rounds if they werent as well conditioned as he is. when you got skill and height thats dangerous. thats what we see.

and you know the old Merchant saying " A good big man beats a good little man if they are evenly matched"

am i saying Paul is as skilled as PBF, hell no. nobody is. But he is a good big man.

Fine with me. I disagree, but I have nothing at stake in it so I'm not going to argue the point again

But you think a lot of Hatton and Cotto, two guys Margarito would beat. Heigh isn't a problem for a great boxer?? Your knowledge continues to destroy this forum...just do everybody a favor and stop posting

You've been here a month. You don't know what "destroys this forum." You probably won't be here in another month

I'm not biting.

Are you another ESB exile who wants to flame here right away? If you want to flame we have a forum for that, The Thunderdome. And I run that place. This is boxing discussion, and you're not a pleasant guy to talk boxing with, so I won't address you again unless it's in another forum.

[Kobe Bryant]

Skinny Pun is way more of a tougher fight than Hatton or Floyd. He's taller has more reach and is also very quick with a high punch out put. And his stamina is good for 12. By the way I would lean toward Williams. But Floyd would never take this fight.

[CottoOverrated1]

Fine with me. I disagree, but I have nothing at stake in it so I'm not going to argue the point again





You've been here a month. You don't know what "destroys this forum." You probably won't be here in another month

I'm not biting.

Are you another ESB exile who wants to flame here right away? If you want to flame we have a forum for that, The Thunderdome. And I run that place. This is boxing discussion, and you're not a pleasant guy to talk boxing with, so I won't address you again unless it's in another forum.

if you dont mind me asking, on what points do you disagree with me. maybe there is something I am not seeing.

[Grappler_Baki60]

Floyd Mayweather vs Paul Williams

if the unification fight happened today, who wins in your opiniont and how?

I say PBF would win. But if this fight happened I am 100% seriously THAT PAUL WOULD BE THE HARDEST OPONENT PBF HAS EVER FACED PERIOD. The only fighter who can posibly beat floyd is Paul sorry to say I dont see anyone else who could. I've tried to think of oponents and only came up with Paul