Who's the better FIGHTER? Joe Calzaghe or Floyd Mayweathers

[GEOFFHAYES]

What you've got here is, IMO, the greatest British fighter of all-time and the best boxer ever.

[punchers_chance]

Floyd is the better boxer/fighter in my opinion. Were he still at his natural weight, or even at 140 again, he would dominate anyone in front of him. I seriously want to see him fight Cotto so he can embarass a young, undefeated fighter in him prime....for justification purposes.

[adamk1304]

Yeah, how did you score you score that fight again? lol

So mayweather didnt fight in the pocket?, he didnt land the more effective shots, he didnt buckle oscars legs in rounds 5 and 12?

lol.

How did you score that fight?

115-114 for mayweather. mayweather did not fight toe to toe with oscar, whenever oscar landed a few punches he shat himself and ran around the ring taking pot-shots. floyd is a brilliant boxer, but he is not a fighter.

[Technical_Skill]

Calzaghe the better fighter.

As far as ability and resume goes it's very close

Thats it im pretty much done with this thread, calzaghe is the best, i admit, he is a better fighter than the best pound for pound in the world.

What is happening to this place?

lol.

[Technical_Skill]

115-114 for mayweather.

I rest my case, see max Kellermans statement. lol.

[Shanus]

Lol, boxing is a type of fighting.

Mayweather hit baldomir with some heavy handed shots, and didnt get hit, how is he not a better fighter than Calzaghe?

Watch the Bika fight, then watch any mayweather fight and tell me Calzaghe is the better fighter.

I could easily say the same about the first Castillo fight, he looked awful and lost clearly in 99% of peoples opinion.. and Bika was a slip up, if Floyd fought a fighter that dirty and strong he'd look awful too.

They should have put a boxing glove on Bika's head in that fight, because that's all he was landing.

[adamk1304]

I rest my case, see max Kellermans statement. lol.

You think i care what that ****** thinks?

[Technical_Skill]

I could easily say the same about the first Castillo fight, he looked awful and lost clearly in 99% of peoples opinion.. and Bika was a slip up, if Floyd fought a fighter that dirty and strong he'd look awful too.

They should have put a boxing glove on Bika's head in that fight, because that's all he was landing.

Last comment just for you shanus,

Floyd had a torn rotator cuff, we know what happened in the rematch,

It you guys opinion, im gonna try to walk away from this, NSB is just getting rediculous these days

Calzaghe is better than Mayweather, and Friggin Kelly Pavlik is the future of boxing,

Whats the point?

lol.

[bdevils]

[QUOTE=Shanus;2389556]Floyd ran against anybody who was bigger than him,


how many fights have you seen of his? he stood in the pocket against fighters bigger than him on many occasions. and when he is sticking and moving well that's called boxing not running.

[bdevils]

I could easily say the same about the first Castillo fight, he looked awful and lost clearly in 99% of peoples opinion.. and Bika was a slip up, if Floyd fought a fighter that dirty and strong he'd look awful too.

They should have put a boxing glove on Bika's head in that fight, because that's all he was landing.

99% my ass. most of the press had floyd winning the fight. just because it was floyd's toughest fight to date doesn't mean he lost but the champ he is he gave a rematch and proved his point that he is clearly the better fighter besides he can't just blow out every opponent.