Why one judge had it for Oscar

[AllEyesOpen]

Here's a snip from a boxing analyst's column:

.... For the record, judges Tom Kaczmarek scored it 115-113 for De la Hoya while judge Chuck Giampa saw it 116-112 and judge Jerry Roth 115-113 for Mayweather.

By the way, Kaczmarek, 79, authored the 29-page manual "You Be The Boxing Judge."

"Of the three basic fundamentals in scoring a fight, a combination of clean punching and effective aggressiveness are the key factors," he said in the manual. "Whatever else is happening in the round, the fighter who is scoring clean solid punches, forcing the action and getting off first is going to win the round. Skillful ring generalship, which enables the fighter to control his opponent is also significant.

"Good fighters usually possess a combination of good clean punching, effective aggressiveness and ring generalship. They score points and ultimately win rounds. If there is still not a clear winner, considering these factors, then good defense may well become the deciding factor."

Now you know why Kaczmarek scored it for de la Hoya.

On effective agression, I gave about 4 rounds to DLH, but most of the rounds were won by Mayweather with clean solid punches, getting of first & ring generalship.

[wmute]

Floyd was more hurt than Oscar apart from at one point of the fight. Floyd was more damaged than oscar. Oscar landed the harder shots. His punches were more effective because they were harder and caused more damage.

when did you see floyd more hurt? when oscar hit his arms on the ropes? i did no see Floyd hurt more than Oscar. In fact I doubt Floyd was ever hurt at all, because Oscar is a terrific finisher, and he would have jumped on him.

Oscar landed body punches, but if you wanna talk about how effective they were... the answer is in floyd being fresh as a rose in round 12, where oscar was buckled by a body punch by floyd.

the only thing that Oscar really did offensively speaking (which i give all possible credit) is busting floyd's eye with the jab, in the early part of the fight.