Why I scored the fight 120-108 Mayweather

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tito yuca
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jul 2006
    • 1843
    • 237
    • 233
    • 8,377

    #1

    Why I scored the fight 120-108 Mayweather

    I believe Floyd won every round convincingly. People (and judges are included in this category) tend to forget that the criteria for judging a fight is EFFECTIVE aggression. See that? EFFECTIVE. The other 3 categories are defense, clean punching, and ring generalship. Oscar landed less shots than Floyd and threw a lot more. This means that his aggression was NOT effective, and what makes a fighter's aggression uneffective is the defensive skills of the other. This means that even in rounds that they landed about the same number of punches, they have to go to Floyd because HE MADE OSCAR MISS. This means his defense was dictating the course of the fight, and this gives him point in the "ring generalship" category.

    Another thing Oscar fans say is that he was pressing the action by moving forward, while Floyd was retreading. Floyd moves in every direction to get his opponents off guard and to make himself a harder target to hit, and this fight displayed this brilliantly. Oscar says he doesn't know what was wrong with his jab and people wonder why he didn't throw it that much, well, he didn't use it much because HE WAS MISSING and it is catastophric to a fighter's ego and pride (especially one of Oscar's stature) to be missing punches. They get so discouraged that they starts throwing less, and selecting their shots more carefully to make sure that they land. Another factor why he threw less is because he was tired, he was visibly tired after the 4th round because Floyd was making him move around so much and throw many punches in hopes of catching him.

    Another thing those in favor of Oscar say was how he handled the fight when Floyd went to the ropes. Notice I said WHEN FLOYD WENT TO THE ROPES, not "when Oscar took Floyd to the ropes". If anyone has seen Mayweather fight before, they know he goes to the ropes and corners purposedly in order to make fighters miss. Oscars punches when Floyd was cornered were LAUGHABLE. They were slow, weak, telegraphed, and not at all crisp, and caused absolutely NO damage.

    Like Max Kellerman said, this was a virtuoso performance by Floyd. People said Floyd would be slower at this weight, he wasn't. They said when Oscar hit him flush he'd get hurt, he wasn't. Some even said all it would take to knock him down would be ONE Oscar left hook - LMFAO. They also said the smaller ring would negate Floyd's movement and the 10 oz. gloves would decrease his handspeed. Nothing that those rooting for Oscar predicted came true. What I saw was the Baldomir all over again, but with a slightly more accurate opponent. Baldomir landed 12% of his shots and Oscar landed 21% - hardly a major difference. If Floyd's opponent on May 5th was not named Oscar de la Hoya, everyone would have scored this a shutout as well.
  • DA1CATAS
    Birth of a Monster
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Apr 2006
    • 4393
    • 207
    • 17
    • 11,092

    #2
    lol... look I like Mayweather Also.. I think he's the best P4P and I think he won the fight Fairly...

    I see some valid points you made....*(though most won't read)*

    BUT lol It was not 120-108

    Comment

    • !! $iN
      • Mar 2026
      • 0
      • 83
      • 0

      #3
      I agree with some of your points, but the rounds Mayweather lost he was just too inactive. It's not like DLH took the rounds. It was more like Mayweather gave him those rounds. If Mayweather would have been active throughout, he could have shut DLH out easily...

      Comment

      • tito yuca
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jul 2006
        • 1843
        • 237
        • 233
        • 8,377

        #4
        I truly believe that Oscar's name and status in the sport is what makes people think he won some rounds. Floyd landed more and made him miss, what does it matter which direction the fighters were moving? Landing more than the other fighter and making him miss is what wins a fight, period.

        Comment

        • jack_the_rippuh
          I to your mom..
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • May 2004
          • 31699
          • 1,148
          • 627
          • 65,521

          #5
          That's what happened when you only pay attention to what one fighter is doing.
          I know that sounds like a smart-alec response, but I use to do that to.

          Anyway, I disagree. It definitely wasn't 120-108. I had it 8 rounds to 4 the first time and 9 rounds to 3 the second time.

          Comment

          • Mattyp151
            Contender
            Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
            • Oct 2005
            • 236
            • 12
            • 2
            • 6,580

            #6
            One word:

            Yikes.

            Comment

            • tito yuca
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jul 2006
              • 1843
              • 237
              • 233
              • 8,377

              #7
              Originally posted by $iN
              I agree with some of your points, but the rounds Mayweather lost he was just too inactive. It's not like DLH took the rounds. It was more like Mayweather gave him those rounds. If Mayweather would have been active throughout, he could have shut DLH out easily...
              That's what I told my friends as the fight went down. Even in those rounds, they landed about the same, and what made me give them to Floyd was that he did this while throwing less punches, which means his defense was an important factor.

              If people use the urban myth that Pep won a round without throwing a punch as a testament to his greatness, but don't see Floyd winning every single round of this fight, it just shows how biased against him they are or how they are intimidated by Oscar's name and feel uneasy about him being shut out.

              Comment

              • Technical_Skill
                Into The Deep
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Apr 2007
                • 5736
                • 523
                • 219
                • 12,694

                #8
                Originally posted by tito yuca
                I believe Floyd won every round convincingly. People (and judges are included in this category) tend to forget that the criteria for judging a fight is EFFECTIVE aggression. See that? EFFECTIVE. The other 3 categories are defense, clean punching, and ring generalship. Oscar landed less shots than Floyd and threw a lot more. This means that his aggression was NOT effective, and what makes a fighter's aggression uneffective is the defensive skills of the other. This means that even in rounds that they landed about the same number of punches, they have to go to Floyd because HE MADE OSCAR MISS. This means his defense was dictating the course of the fight, and this gives him point in the "ring generalship" category.

                Another thing Oscar fans say is that he was pressing the action by moving forward, while Floyd was retreading. Floyd moves in every direction to get his opponents off guard and to make himself a harder target to hit, and this fight displayed this brilliantly. Oscar says he doesn't know what was wrong with his jab and people wonder why he didn't throw it that much, well, he didn't use it much because HE WAS MISSING and it is catastophric to a fighter's ego and pride (especially one of Oscar's stature) to be missing punches. They get so discouraged that they starts throwing less, and selecting their shots more carefully to make sure that they land. Another factor why he threw less is because he was tired, he was visibly tired after the 4th round because Floyd was making him move around so much and throw many punches in hopes of catching him.

                Another thing those in favor of Oscar say was how he handled the fight when Floyd went to the ropes. Notice I said WHEN FLOYD WENT TO THE ROPES, not "when Oscar took Floyd to the ropes". If anyone has seen Mayweather fight before, they know he goes to the ropes and corners purposedly in order to make fighters miss. Oscars punches when Floyd was cornered were LAUGHABLE. They were slow, weak, telegraphed, and not at all crisp, and caused absolutely NO damage.

                Like Max Kellerman said, this was a virtuoso performance by Floyd. People said Floyd would be slower at this weight, he wasn't. They said when Oscar hit him flush he'd get hurt, he wasn't. Some even said all it would take to knock him down would be ONE Oscar left hook - LMFAO. They also said the smaller ring would negate Floyd's movement and the 10 oz. gloves would decrease his handspeed. Nothing that those rooting for Oscar predicted came true. What I saw was the Baldomir all over again, but with a slightly more accurate opponent. Baldomir landed 12% of his shots and Oscar landed 21% - hardly a major difference. If Floyd's opponent on May 5th was not named Oscar de la Hoya, everyone would have scored this a shutout as well.
                I couldnt bring myself to read this.

                I like your posts,

                But 120-108 to mayweather is absurd.

                Shocking.

                Comment

                • Mozza
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Sep 2006
                  • 3802
                  • 233
                  • 174
                  • 12,277

                  #9
                  120-108 to Mayweather? Are you hoping Floyd reads this and decides to become your friend since you obviously think the sun shines from the crack in his ass?

                  Get real mate.

                  Comment

                  • DA1CATAS
                    Birth of a Monster
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Apr 2006
                    • 4393
                    • 207
                    • 17
                    • 11,092

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Mozza
                    120-108 to Mayweather? Are you hoping Floyd reads this and decides to become your friend since you obviously think the sun shines from the crack in his ass?

                    Get real mate.
                    lmao..imma have to use that one!

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP