Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[VIVA MEXICO!!!]

No, judges do....

i dont need no judges to tell me what i saw with my own eyes. i bet you think casamayor beat santa cruz since thats what the judges said. i know a robbery when i see one.

[Sweet Pete]

No, judges do....

That is the case yes, but there are plenty of judges decisions I'm against as well. In a fight this close, I can see someone giving it to either, but I can't sit there and listen to anyone saying either dominated or pretending it was a blatant robbery.

[beauty]

VIVA, what I think is that at this point, IT DOES NOT MATTER!!!! Opinions at any stage after it's final are so irrelevant. Mayweather won. He won. Period. Castillo presented a wonderful argument indeed, but in the end, the judges agreed Mayweather presented the better argument. It is as simple as that and debating this now does nothing to change the final result; Floyd Mayweather BEAT Castillo not once, but twice. Deal with it.

[VIVA MEXICO!!!]

VIVA, what I think is that at this point, IT DOES NOT MATTER!!!! Opinions at any stage after it's final are so irrelevant. Mayweather won. He won. Period. Castillo presented a wonderful argument indeed, but in the end, the judges agreed Mayweather presented the better argument. It is as simple as that and debating this now does nothing to change the final result; Floyd Mayweather BEAT Castillo not once, but twice. Deal with it.

so you agree with the judges in casamayor-santa cruz??? or do you just pick and choose when you agree with the judges to suit your nuthugging???

[beauty]

so you agree with the judges in casamayor-santa cruz??? or do you just pick and choose when you agree with the judges to suit your nuthugging???

Viva, you are hopeless my love.


BTW, I have called NO ONE any names on here. Refrain from calling me names, k. Thank you.

[VIVA MEXICO!!!]

Viva, you are hopeless my love.


BTW, I have called NO ONE any names on here. Refrain from calling me names, k. Thank you.

you are just like mayweather DUCKING the question.

[beauty]

VIVA, what does Casamayor/Santa Cruz have to do with Mayweather/Castillo I and my opinion of the decision?

Never did I say Castillo was a bum when he fought Mayweather. Never did I say in their first fight, Mayweather beat his ass. Never did I say the fight was not close. I never said anything to discredit my ability to see the reasoning of some to feel emphatically Mayweather lost. The fight was close, however not too close to call. Mayweather landed more credibly and more accurately, IMO.

Stop spending so much time on Floyd. It's just not healthy, dear.

[Silencers]

I had Castillo winning by a point.

[Sin City]

DEBATE SETTLED. CASTILLO WON THE FIGHT. END THREAD!

[apollo creed]

close, but castillo will always edge it on my card.

i cant beleive floyd has over 100 votes here, after all it was pretty obvious castillo got hosed.