Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[cortdawg25]

How do you win rounds by throwing 30 punches per round and landing far less?

Actually it's all basic common sense.

did he or did he not win the 1st five rounds?

[MBL]

oh god I must be bored, I just read the first 8 pages of this thread
it was like walking around in circles trying to find a way out of the amazon

[.Mik.]

No, it seems just haters and alts voted. The majority of people who actually posted feel that Mayweather won...

If you werent going to respect the result of the poll that YOU set up to 'settle the debate', then perhaps you shouldnt have bothered setting it up.

[-Hyperion-]

If you werent going to respect the result of the poll that YOU set up to 'settle the debate', then perhaps you shouldnt have bothered setting it up.

LOL

[Guest]

If you werent going to respect the result of the poll that YOU set up to 'settle the debate', then perhaps you shouldnt have bothered setting it up.

I made it public just to see which votes could be taken seriously. Take out the alts and irrational haters and it's probably 50/50...

[Cletus Funk]

I made it public just to see which votes could be taken seriously. Take out the alts and irrational haters and it's probably 50/50...

Then take out the Floyd ****-jockeys and it'll be 75/25.

[DiegoFuego]

If you scored that fight for Castillo, you are a sorry excuse for a judge. Punches to the back, back of the head, and shoulders are not supposed to be counted. If you do count them, you can't tell me they're as good as punches that drill you in the face. Mayweather won the first 4 easily, maybe the first 5. No way he lost that fight.

[Guest]

If you scored that fight for Castillo, you are a sorry excuse for a judge. Punches to the back, back of the head, and shoulders are not supposed to be counted. If you do count them, you can't tell me they're as good as punches that drill you in the face. Mayweather won the first 4 easily, maybe the first 5. No way he lost that fight.

There's no way Castillo won more than 6 rounds in that fight. That's the most I could give him if I gave Castillo every benefit of the doubt...

[DiegoFuego]

There's no way Castillo won more than 6 rounds in that fight. That's the most I could give him if I gave Castillo every benefit of the doubt...

and everyone on this poll knows it to whether they admit it or not. even if you give Castillo every close round, it's a draw at best.

[hugh grant]

I think who won this fight aint even the issue now. It was very close and it has been said that PBF hasnt lost b4 and hasnt really come close to losing. Well he has been close to losing. Very close to the point people cant decide who won. PBF has the win so we will have to accept that i suppose.