Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[JakeNDaBox]

I had it 113-113, but believing that if someone had to win, it was Floyd - just not by the ridiculous scores posted by the three blind mice at ringside.

Castillo did A LOT better than people expected; I thought HBO got caught up in all of that (in addition to their not being pleased with Floyd prior to the telecast, or really since) and called it the way they wanted people to see it. But while "almost" counts for something in horseshoes, it still translates to 2nd place, or at best tied for 1st, in boxing. Such describes Castillo's peformance that night.

[Run]

116-112 Jose Luis Castillo.

He landed more punches, more punches at a higher accuracy, chased Floyd around and initiated the fight, and dictated the fight by closing the gap virtually every single round. The rounds I did score for Floyd were ones that were close and could have gone either way.........but Floyd's 1 and done tactics won them because of his defense and not getting hit cleanly.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[KingTito]

mayweather won, whether you think he earned it or not, he was still given the decision. on their records it's a loss for castillo and a victory for mayweather.

[Easy-E]

116-112 Jose Luis Castillo.

He landed more punches, more punches at a higher accuracy, chased Floyd around and initiated the fight, and dictated the fight by closing the gap virtually every single round. The rounds I did score for Floyd were ones that were close and could have gone either way.........but Floyd's 1 and done tactics won them because of his defense and not getting hit cleanly.

Your aware that score makes no sense becuase of the two point deductions in rounds 8 and 10, right??
Maybe you should watch the fight and rescore it.

[Super_Lightweight]

mayweather won, whether you think he earned it or not, he was still given the decision. on their records it's a loss for castillo and a victory for mayweather.

Oh, thanks for clearing that up. So we should never debate the results rendered by the judges, because they are God.

Now I understand perfectly.

[GunStar]

Your aware that score makes no sense becuase of the two point deductions in rounds 8 and 10, right??
Maybe you should watch the fight and rescore it.

Good detective work!

[Guest]

Your aware that score makes no sense becuase of the two point deductions in rounds 8 and 10, right??
Maybe you should watch the fight and rescore it.

[GunStar]

I've been here for a long time and I don't even know half the people that voted for Castillo, shal we say alts.

[Pugilistic™]

floyd won the fight

not by alot but he did

[Guest]

I've been here for a long time and I don't even know half the people that voted for Castillo, shal we say alts.

Most of the people who post say that Floyd won the fight, so you might be right about all the alts. Many of the ones that aren't alts are known haters...