Was Valuev Robbed?

[!! Mr. Soprano]

I feel that with as many robberies Valuev got away with in the passed, this fight could have gone either way.. but 117-111?

I kind of agree with the commentator, this fight was kind of hard to score.. and I wouldn't be surprised if the judges gave it to Valuev.


What are your thoughts?

[GunStar]

Yea I agree this was a close fight could've gone to either men, I really didn't keep score but I know it was a close fight!

There was no clear cut winner in my eyes!

[Derranged]

Once again... HELL NO. 9 rounds to 3 was appropriate for this fight. Valuev did not land much, and he kept getting hit flush with that left. And in the latter rounds, those left hands looked like they started to bother Valuev a little, plus he looked pretty tired. Chagaev landed many more punches. I cant see how anyone could've had this fight close.

[EliteSoldier]

Once again... I cant see how anyone could've had this fight close.

You sound really biased on the way you type... Maybe thats why everyone's ignoring you.

[Derranged]

You sound really biased on the way you type... Maybe thats why everyone's ignoring you.

Not really, Im just stating what I saw. And Im not being ignored and I certaintly was not owned.

[Derranged]

You sound really biased on the way you type... Maybe thats why everyone's ignoring you.

Im just stating what I feel is obvious. And Im not being ignored and I certaintly was not owned.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Once again... HELL NO. 9 rounds to 3 was appropriate for this fight. Valuev did not land much, and he kept getting hit flush with that left. And in the latter rounds, those left hands looked like they started to bother Valuev a little, plus he looked pretty tired. Chagaev landed many more punches. I cant see how anyone could've had this fight close.

Did you see Valuev / Donald? I feel that Donald was able to land a lot more of those clean shots you're talking about.. but check who won that fight.

My hat is off to Chagaev, who executed a perfect plan in the fight, great movement, great strategy... he looked like he has sure done his homework and worked really hard... but again.. 117 - 111?

I don't think that victory was THAT convincing

[Derranged]

Did you see Valuev / Donald? I feel that Donald was able to land a lot more of those clean shots you're talking about.. but check who won that fight.

My hat is off to Chagaev, who executed a perfect plan in the fight, great movement, great strategy... he looked like he has sure done his homework and worked really hard... but again.. 117 - 111?

I don't think that victory was THAT convincing

Nothing is iron clad. Perhaps a few of the ROUNDS were close and debateable. IMO, Chagaev won more rounds.

[ELPacman]

Man, if he was robbed. That was the best robbing I've ever seen. Long live Marciano's record! Or at least until someone worthy beats it. Until then, may it rest in peace.

[Drunken Cat]

**** no he wasnt robbed. I scored it 115-113 Chagaev. The right man one the fight.