Did Marquez win????

[-Antonio-]

JMM won by 2 points if the knockdown wasnt counted. Barerra was landing a lot of jabs too. Marquez landed harder shots more often, and got of his combinations first. Still eventhough Marquez dominated that whole 7th round it should be 9-8 Barerra.

[amaru]

barrera won the fight, he should have got a knockdown, and he threw more and landed more punches, he was robbed!! the judges were horrendous on all 3 fights tonight!!!!

i had barrera winnin by 1 point

[deuce_drop]

i had marquez winning by two rounds but that is going by not counting the knockdown, had that been marquez still was up a point on my card. but overall i think that the miss call on the knockdown was messed up and that barerra got screwed, then agains i thought juarez beat barerra in their first fight so if the call stands i guess you could say that things are balanced in the respect.


overall the scoring by the judges was close to being the worst i've seen. the ponce de leon fight was correct to a certain extent, but Dhop vs Forbes was a travisty, even hopkins corner was saying he needed a KO to win, ploying with him to go for the KO because he was behind, what ever fight the judges saw was beyond me. very bad representation of the nevada commission and boxing.

[Addison]

anyone with agrain of sense would have to score that fight for marquez.

THANK YOU.

That's what I'm saying.. But that's because I filtered my choice through the actual circumstances and factors involved.

Barrera barely initiated. ****ing barely..

He was still brilliant, and he was the better man in the intial..

That means something to me.


Much respect to the Great Marco Antonio Barrera.

[moy22487]

I could see the fight going for jmm or barrera. Judges and the ref were all idiots.
But honestly marco did need to lose a point for hitting a man while he was down. Point being taken away is ok there. Rules say when a fighter hits the floor (slip or knockdown) you can't hit any more, there is no warning needed to take points away. (Note jmm was also hit while on the floor in his 3rd knockdown againts pac, pac lost no points)

But that's also a knockdown so that should of been a 9 8 round. But jmm did have a good round besides being dropped. I don't know if I'm allowed but I made that a 9 9 round.

Over all I think I had it 113 114 for marco, but some rounds could of gone either way, I can say a close victory for jmm is decent scoreing

[Njord777]

You know, I think it was a close fight. But the fact that the judges made several bad calls during the night, and that the margin was so wide in favor of Marquez- I have a bitter taste in my mouth. One judge only gave a round or two to Barrera. Insanity. The scoring was uniformly poor.

[niceguy45]

no, i had 114-113 barrera that was a bad decesion by the judges overall,
at least not by UD would of been better buti still think barrera won by 1point

[comepana]

I thought JMM won a close but clear decision tonight.The round 7 should've been 8-7 to Marquez, Barrera scored a beautiful KD but Marquez delivered a can of whoop ass not to mention that really cheap shot of Barrera that could've been a DQ. I can't wait for the rematch...

[eyeloveboxing]

THEN U DONT KNOW SCORING BECUASE HE LOST 4 POINT IN THAT ROUND

hey faag... if the knock down was scored, it would have been 9-9 round. JMM was winning 2:30 of the round.

[Marcos]

ou have to take it from the champ/legend

I could see the fight going for jmm or barrera. Judges and the ref were all idiots.
But honestly marco did need to lose a point for hitting a man while he was down. Point being taken away is ok there. Rules say when a fighter hits the floor (slip or knockdown) you can't hit any more, there is no warning needed to take points away. (Note jmm was also hit while on the floor in his 3rd knockdown againts pac, pac lost no points)

But that's also a knockdown so that should of been a 9 8 round. But jmm did have a good round besides being dropped. I don't know if I'm allowed but I made that a 9 9 round.

Over all I think I had it 113 114 for marco, but some rounds could of gone either way, I can say a close victory for jmm is decent scoreing

Tough call between 2 tough great Mexican fighters. I felt a draw or spilt. The judges cheapen the Fight. No way was is it by the margin they called it.
Barrerra controlled the action, but Marquez was the agressor and made it an action fight. I wanted Marquez but at the end, I felt Barerra should have kept his title. Oh well.... Rematch!