Oscar fought 8 undefeated fighters....Floyd 1 !

[guru]

All those fighters at 147 and down would have lost to him, that's not that bold of statement. Vargas I beleive was at 154 but he would still lose too. The whitaker that oscar fought would have lost as well, but the Whitaker that fought Roger Mayweather would have been a close fight.

i'm not sure pbf can beat mosely now, much less back when shane was undefeated...

[Benny Leonard]

Oscar was also fighting in a better "era" in my opinion.

But yeah, Oscar was the man. The guy is fighting the P4P #1 at this stage of his career. Other than the allegations I just heard about him trying to act like a mob boss showing up with a bag of cash to lure Manny Pac to sign, he is great for the sport.

[Benny Leonard]

i'm not sure pbf can beat mosely now, much less back when shane was undefeated...

Shane was great back in the lower weights. Shane that fought Oscar the first time would of beaten Floyd, in my opinion.

I would heavily favor Oscar and Shane over Cotto and Hatton as well.

[Ether]

True Story.

[cortdawg25]

i'm not sure pbf can beat mosely now, much less back when shane was undefeated...

WHAT!! Did you see that collazo fight? Mosley wasn't all that nice in the fight, but it was better than his Vargas fight. Mosley at 135 could have given Floyd a run for his $$$, but not at 147. The guy struggled with Estrada for christ sakes. Estrada was game though, but Mosley struggled still and didn't he struggle with Gomez too?

[cortdawg25]

[QUOTE=Benny Leonard;2183608]Shane was great back in the lower weights. Shane that fought Oscar the first time would of beaten Floyd, in my opinion.

I would heavily favor Oscar and Shane over Cotto and Hatton as well.[/QUOTE]

I agree with that part. It's a shame that these new guys who supposedly can't take out the older fighters. It kinda makes you wonder about boxing now, are these new guys just mediocre or are these old guys just that good.

[Del Coqui]

Both PBF and DLH are great fighters, resume and experience has to go to DLH, youth and activity to PBF. Lets get serious thou, Oscar hasn't been an active fighter in a few years now, PBF has never fought at 154 and besides he's a lightweight, Jr WW at the most. DLH is gonna beat up a smaller fighter who hasn't won impressively in over 3 years? If PBF ever pulls a win fair and square over DLH, no doubt he should be considered one of the best fighters of our era, but until then he's just a great fighter who's about to pull out of the sport without ever reaching the stardom he thinks he has.

[Pac_attack]

WHAT!! Did you see that collazo fight? Mosley wasn't all that nice in the fight, but it was better than his Vargas fight. Mosley at 135 could have given Floyd a run for his $$$, but not at 147. The guy struggled with Estrada for christ sakes. Estrada was game though, but Mosley struggled still and didn't he struggle with Gomez too?

HE KTFO of Gomez

[-EX-]

It won't matter when Floyd gives Oscar boxing lesson May 5th.

[brownpimp88]

Floyd has fought 4 very good fighters, with genaro hernandez being the best. However, he has yet to fight a true "elite". I hope he doesnt lose and fold just like nasem hamed did.

Oscar has fought 5 very good fighters and he has defeated 2 elites. However, those two elites were old and past it when he beat them.