who fought better opponents.....which one is a better list ?

[niceguy45]

we know PBF vs DHL is going to be one of the biggest event in boxing history, we have discussed advantages/disadvantages for both,
which one of the two fought has a better resumè list????

DLH's opponents

Ricardo Mayorga- 05/06/06
Bernard Hopkins-09/18/04 <----- the only legit lossFelix Sturm-06/05/04
Shane Mosley-09/13/03 <---- i had DHL ahead going into the 12
Luis Ramon Campas-05/03/03
Fernando Vargas-09/14/02
Javier Castillejo-06/23/01
Arturo Gatti-03/24/01 <----prime gatti ?
Shane Mosley-06/17/00 <----a fight could of been a draw
Derrell Coley-02/26/00
Felix Trinidad-09/18/99 <-----i think DON KING won this one not TITO
Oba Carr-05/22/99
Ike Quartey-02/13/99
Julio Cesar Chavez-09/18/98
Patrick Charpentier-06/13/98
Wilfredo Rivera-12/06/97
Hector Camacho-09/13/97
David Kamau-06/14/97
Pernell Whitaker-04/12/97
Miguel Angel Gonzalez-01/18/97
Julio Cesar Chavez-06/07/96 <-----this style DHL should use agains floyd
Darryl Tyson-02/09/96
Jesse James Leija-12/15/95
Genaro Hernandez-09/09/95
Rafael Ruelas-05/06/95 <-----this is one of two ruelas underrated bros.
Juan Molina-02/18/95
John Avila-12/10/94
Carl Griffith-11/18/94
Jorge Paez-07/29/94
Giorgio Campanella-05/27/94
Jimmi Bredahl-03/05/94
Narciso Valenzuela-10/30/93
Angelo Nunez-08/27/93
Renaldo Carter-08/14/93
Troy Dorsey-06/07/93
Frank Avelar-05/08/93
Mike Grable-04/06/93
Jeff Mayweather-03/13/93
Curtis Strong-02/06/93
Paris Alexander-01/03/93
Clifford Hicks-12/12/92
Lamar Williams-11/23/92

i don't care what anybody says that's a pretty nice list

ight lets go with pretty boy floyd's list of opponents

PBF's list

Carlos Baldomir-04/11/06
Zab Judah-04/08/06
Sharmba Mitchell-11/19/05
Arturo Gatti-06/25/05
Henry Bruseles-01/22/05
DeMarcus Corley-05/22/04
Phillip N'dou-11/01/03
Victoriano Sosa-04/19/03
Jose Luis Castillo-12/07/02 <----got away with it
Jose Luis Castillo-04/20/02 <----lucky win
Jesus Chavez-11/10/01
Carlos Hernandez-05/26/01
Diego Corrales-01/20/01 <-----don't know WTF happened to chico[B]Emanuel Augustus-10/21/00 <-----lmao
Gregorio Vargas-03/18/00
Carlos Gerena-09/11/99
Justin Juuko-05/22/99
Carlos Alberto Ramon Rios-02/17/99
Angel Manfredy-12/19/98
Genaro Hernandez-10/03/98
Tony Pep-06/14/98
Gustavo Fabian Cuello-04/18/98
Miguel Melo-03/23/98
Sam Girard-02/28/98
Hector Arroyo-01/09/98
Angelo Nunez-11/20/97
Felipe Garcia-10/14/97
Louie Leija-09/06/97
Jesus Chavez-07/12/97
Larry O'Shields-06/14/97
Tony Duran-05/09/97
Kino Rodriguez-04/12/97
Edgar Ayala-02/01/97
Jerry Cooper-01/18/97
Reggie Sanders-11/30/96
Roberto Apodaca-10/11/96


all very competitive lists.....which one is better ??????

[brownpimp88]

even oscar admits he lost to mosley the first time, by the way 4 of oscar's wins were considered gifts or very close decisions.

[Kobe Bryant]

I'll go with De La Hoya. Just for the simple fact that he fought Hopkins. Floyd hasn't faced anyone as good as Hopkins.

[BrooklynBomber]

DLH and its not even close, when was the last time PBF really fought an alite fighter. DLH got Tito, Mosley, Hops, Quartey and many many others.

[K-Nan]

This isn't even a valid question. Oscar has the better resume. But then again, he has the best resume of any active fighter.


Oh, and you don't know what happend to Chico? Floyd happened!

[niceguy45]

This isn't even a valid question. Oscar has the better resume. But then again, he has the best resume of any active fighter.


Oh, and you don't know what happend to Chico? Floyd happened!

im saying chico looked like he was on drugs or something, i don't understand

[Kobe Bryant]

im saying chico looked like he was on drugs or something, i don't understand

Yeah he was all ****ed up. They said he was going through personal problems at the time. Not to discredit Mayweather because he was great that night. Chico wasn't going to quit but his corner waived him off. He was ****ing pissed I think he started cussing his dad out.

[K-Nan]

im saying chico looked like he was on drugs or something, i don't understand

Nah, he had personal problems at the time, but do you think that it would have been ANY different on ANY night? Not unless he took steroids for that glass chin.

[TheEvilSaint]

hmm. oscar fought legends, but beat only a few.

floyd beat the best of his day, but he didnt beat legends.

IMO these are the records:

Oscar De La Hoya:

TKO2 Leija
TKO4 Chavez
TKO8 Chavez
W12 Whitaker (questionable)
W12 Quartey (questionable)
L12 Trinidad (questionable)
L12 x2 Mosley (2nd one is questionable)
TKO5 Gatti
W12 Castillejo
TKO12 Vargas
TKO by 9 Hopkins
TKO6 Mayorga

vs

Floyd Mayweather Jr:

TKO9 Agustus
TKO10 Corrales
W12 Hernandez
TKO9 J. Chavez
W12 x2 Castillo (1st one is questionable)
TKO6 Gatti
W12 Judah
W12 Baldomir

oscar faced legends, but lost to most. floyd beat the best of his day, but not legends.

its a matter of opinion, but i think oscar's record will stand the test of time. not to say floyd's record wont, but floyd's opposition wasnt as good as oscar's.

[niceguy45]

Nah, he had personal problems at the time, but do you think that it would have been ANY different on ANY night? Not unless he took steroids for that glass chin.

i think i would of been somewhat different if corrales had his mind clear or at least showed that he wanted to fight